DEAR DR. BLONZ: I keep seeing messages that foods are now mineral-deficient, and we need supplements to prevent deficiencies. Which minerals are currently believed to be essential for good health? Are there still as many of these as there used to be, or has modern agriculture made it so foods have less? -- T.S., San Diego
DEAR T.S.: A mineral is loosely defined as anything in nature that is not animal or vegetable. Minerals are inorganic chemical elements required for specific structures or metabolic functions; "inorganic" means they do not contain the element carbon. The body cannot synthesize or change minerals; they don't provide calories and are needed only in small amounts relative to protein, fat and carbohydrate. The body can become more efficient in recycling some nutrients; still, prolonged insufficient intakes lead to a failure to thrive and the development of deficiency diseases, the expression of which depends on the nutrient.
Minerals needed in more significant amounts include calcium, chloride, magnesium, phosphorous, potassium and sodium. Chromium, copper, fluoride, iodine, iron, manganese, molybdenum, selenium and zinc are equally essential, but needed only in trace amounts. (Check the National Library of Medicine's page on minerals at b.link/5wfsdv.) All the minerals the body needs can be found in food.
Think of plants as miners, pulling the mineral elements out of their environment, unable to grow and thrive if an essential mineral is absent. It follows that essential minerals that leave with the plant at harvest need to be replaced using fertilizer or compost, or subsequent yields will drop.
Minerals that are not essential for the plant can also end up in the food; what enters can vary by mineral, soil and weather -- even among different varieties of the same fruit, vegetable or grain. The plant's overall nutrient content can also vary by the length of time the plant has had to grow. Although the differences might not be significant, a plant picked green that ripens after harvest may not have the same total nutrient content as one allowed to ripen "on the vine."
For example, whole foods grown in iodine-rich or selenium-rich soils tend to have more of these nutrients than the same type of food grown in soils with lesser amounts of these minerals. Of historical interest, iodine-rich soils tend to be close to the coast, with less iodine found in foods grown inland. The incidence of goiter, an expression of iodine deficiency, once correlated with distance from the coast and led to the introduction of iodized salt in 1924. The typical diet in the U.S. is now iodine-sufficient, so iodized salt is no longer needed.
While we may have turned to varieties better suited to transportation and storage, it is incorrect to say today's fruits, vegetables or grains will provide any fewer essential nutrients than the same varieties would have provided in the past. Nutrient data tables, such as those provided by the USDA, present the nutrients expected in a particular food (fdc.nal.usda.gov/). Finally, check the source of the "foods are now mineral-deficient" messages you're seeing; aside from being misleading, you may find they originated from a party seeking to sell supplements.
Send questions to: "On Nutrition," Ed Blonz, c/o Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO, 64106. Send email inquiries to questions@blonz.com. Due to the volume of mail, personal replies cannot be provided.