DEAR DR. BLONZ: Please help settle a family debate. It is my impression that when vegetables are boiled with no lid on the pot, some nutrients leave with the steam. My son says that all the nutrients stay in the cooking water. -- J.A., Hayward, California
Advertisement
DEAR J.A.: Your son is much closer to accuracy, but there is one nutrient that does, indeed, exit with the steam: water! The steam/water itself is a nutrient, which means you and your son both have some claim to correctness.
The cooking process can cause a breakdown of some vitamins, but these are not lost with the steam. For an article on how cooking affects nutrients, see b.link/xrz7zcd.
DEAR DR. BLONZ: This is a follow-up to your recent column on repelling mosquitoes. When we went camping years ago, we learned that Avon Skin So Soft Bath Oil worked well to repel mosquitoes. We liked using it rather than applying insect repellents that contained other chemicals. This could be a good option for young children. -- G.F., San Ramon, California
DEAR G.F.: After my piece on how a particular dietary supplement was ineffective against mosquitoes, I received several notes about Avon Skin So Soft Bath Oil. I recall when the rumors emerged, years ago, that this product could repel mosquitoes; it became a go-to product for many summers and was difficult to find.
Studies were undertaken to verify its efficacy, using a sample population to assess the oil's benefits. The studies failed to find a significant difference in the performance of the oil and a placebo substance. There are various possible explanations for this: 1. The product is indeed ineffective as a mosquito repellent; 2. The placebo selected was equally effective, so there was no difference between the two; or 3. There were other characteristics -- whether genetic, cosmetic or something else -- that were unequally distributed between the groups and these impacted the results.
The bottom line is that the mosquito-repellent effect has not been confirmed. To Avon's credit, the company has never promoted this as a feature of the bath oil product. Consumer Reports has also discussed the issue: see b.link/sajmfx2.
All of that being said, some people may experience good results when using this product to repel mosquitoes, and there is no reason to stop if you are having success.
We do not yet fully understand the individual and combined factors that entice or repel mosquitoes. Any of these can play a role in our odor, and therefore our attractiveness to bugs: what we have recently eaten; the detergent or fabric softener used on our garments; the moisturizers, sunscreens or deodorants on our skin; when we last bathed or exercised; even our stress levels.
It is a wildcard; better to rely on our individual observations of what works for us.
Send questions to: “On Nutrition,” Ed Blonz, c/o Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO, 64106. Send email inquiries to questions@blonz.com. Due to the volume of mail, personal replies cannot be provided.