A married pair of San Diego real estate brokers were in their early 30s in 2010 when they bought their first home, a tiny two bedroom with ample space for the couple and a price tag within their reach.
But within a few years, the pair had their first baby, followed by a set of twins. That’s when they began looking for a much bigger abode to accommodate their growing family, says Justin Gramm, one of the brokers who helped the couple find a home.
While it’s a good bet to make your first home one that could expand to fit your spatial needs for years ahead, he says that’s often impossible from a financial standpoint.
“The moral of the story is to always buy what you can when you can, yet be extremely careful about the property you select,” says Gramm, who heads San Diego-based Globella Buyers Realty, which works exclusively with buyers and takes no listings.
Ivy Zelman, a housing industry analyst based in New York, says would-be first-time buyers find the current real estate market even more challenging than did those trying to break into ownership a decade or two ago. One key factor is that house prices have barely moderated in many areas.
“I think the first-time buyer is really struggling. Mortgage rates have to come down meaningfully to make a difference,” says Zelman, who contends many novice buyers need rates as low as 4.5% to buy their first property.
One approach to saving on rates is to take a “mortgage-buydown” that’s offered by a homebuilder as an incentive to increase or hasten sales. In such a case, the homebuilding firm, using its own connections to select mortgage lenders, pays money upfront to lower the buyers’ mortgage rate.
To entice wannabe homebuyers facing income constraints, up to 70% of homebuilders are currently offering mortgage buydowns, Zelman notes.
Unfortunately, not all popular metro areas feature newly constructed homes that are reasonably convenient and affordable for first-time buyers. Therefore, the primary inventory in those areas typically involves resale properties.
Here are a few pointers for first-time buyers hoping to close a deal in 2026:
-- Look for a property with your future lifestyle in mind.
First-timers sometimes make the mistake of expecting to keep their property for just a few years before moving on.
But Tom Early, an independent Ohio real estate broker, strongly advises clients to buy with a time horizon of at least five years, due to the high transaction costs associated with selling one house and moving to another.
“These days, you can’t necessarily count on appreciation in home values to bail you out on transition costs if you wind up selling in just a couple of years,” Early says.
-- Avoid picking an oddball property.
“You don’t want to buy a contemporary in a neighborhood full of colonials,” says Mark Nash, author of “1001 Tips for Buying and Selling a Home.”
The problem with what Nash calls “the odd-man-out house” is that one day it could be hard to sell.
“Most people feel safer about their investment if the place they buy looks like all their neighbors’ homes,” he says.
-- Identify your priorities to better compare your housing options.
Since 1981, when Early entered the real estate field, he’s worked with several thousand buyers. Experience has taught him that purchasers who write down their priorities are less likely to err.
Before you go home shopping, Early encourages you to compose two lists. One should itemize “must-have” home features and the other -- a “wish list” -- should include features you could live without if trade-offs must be made.
-- Exclude the biggest house in your neighborhood of choice.
Some buyers are always tempted to seek out the biggest houses in a neighborhood. But Early explains that such a house is unlikely to gain as much value as an average-sized place in the same area.
Granted, the biggest house will likely appreciate, assuming it’s located in a popular area. Still, its owners will get less of a boost in value on a per-square-foot basis than will the owners of a smaller house, because the median home will set the standard for the area.
-- Avoid a fixer-upper with serious issues.
An increasing number of buyers are covering the cost of a professional home inspection to help identify potential defects in the property they’ve selected. Realtors generally support the involvement of independent home inspectors.
But agents also note that occasionally first-time buyers will go forward with a home purchase despite an inspector’s report that outlines worrisome faults.
Early says buyers who encounter major problems with a property-- such as trouble with the foundation or unsafe electrical wiring -- are often well-advised to simply walk away.
“You’ve got to let go emotionally of any house that’s a serious fixer-upper—unless you’re extraordinarily handy,” he says.
-- Slow down the property selection process.
As Early says, a good real estate agent will listen attentively to buyers when they express housing needs and preferences. The agent should also show diligence in pre-screening properties that seem well suited to the buyers’ needs.
But buyers should be wary of any agent who tries to pressure them to take a particular house—especially one they’re ambivalent about.
“The right agent is one who respects your time, your money and your priorities,” Early says.
(To contact Ellen James Martin, email her at ellenjamesmartin@gmail.com.)