DEAR NATALIE: Politics is literally ripping my family apart. My brother and his wife have become more and more “MAGA” over the years. At first, we all accepted it. We recognize that my brother has always been vocal about his beliefs. But there are certain lines you just don’t cross with family. We were at my home for a family dinner that we host once a month to get all of my (six!) siblings and their families together. We have the biggest home, so we always host. Everyone brings food and it’s a great time. My youngest child has recently come out to us as trans. He is using a new name, Jack, and everyone has been incredibly supportive of this. He is 15. If this is how he feels, then we are going to love him for who he is. Jack is an incredibly sweet, kind kid and always was. Everyone loves him. Until this transition, he and my brother got along really well. But my brother won’t even look at him now. He called him an “abomination” at the dinner table. So, my husband threw him and his wife out. It was a terrible scene. Jack, of course, is blaming himself for what happened and is devastated over this. He loves his uncle and doesn’t understand why his uncle suddenly hates him. What do I say to this child? What do I say to my brother who I am furious with? Everyone else in the family agrees with us on this issue. Is there any way to put my family back together? –BROKEN PIECES
Advertisement
DEAR BROKEN PIECES: My heart breaks for your family and especially for Jack. Standing as your authentic self takes a lot of courage. I don’t know if much can truly be done to put this family back together other than time. Unfortunately, extreme beliefs lead to extreme actions. Calling his nephew an “abomination” is something you just can’t take back. Even if your brother were to apologize, the relationship is never going to be what it was. I hope your son has a therapist or someone he can talk to about all of these feelings so that he doesn’t fall into a sense of hopelessness, depression or suicidal ideation. Continue to just support him and love him, which is what you are clearly doing. As for your brother, I would wait a beat before reaching out to him – if you even want to do that. What he did was so hurtful and disrespectful, it may take a long time to recover from it. The reality is, these extremist views push people who buy into them so far into a corner, it’s like they can’t find a way out. An attack on their beliefs becomes an attack on their ego – on their very sense of self. Maybe someday your brother will come around, and I hope for your family’s sake that he does. But if his first words aren’t an apology, I don’t see how you can have any chance for a relationship in the far future.
DEAR NATALIE: A few years ago, I moved into the city where my mom and brother live. I have a great job and a community of friends but my life is missing romance. I don’t know how to “meet” people. I am really family-oriented and am tired of my family ostracizing me because I don’t have a partner. I want to meet someone who I can eventually start a family with but I don’t want to scare them away by leading with that. How soon is too soon to introduce a new date to my family? I feel like whenever I meet someone new, I end up in a position where I don’t know how to communicate to them that I want to date seriously. What are the questions I should be asking on early dates to get to know if things will work long term? –TIRED OF WAITING
DEAR TIRED OF WAITING: I wish I could say online dating was the answer – and I’m not saying you shouldn’t put yourself out there however you choose – but I wouldn’t put all your eggs in that basket. It sounds as though you have built a strong community around you, so lean into social events and keep an open mind. Ask a few friends that you trust if they have anyone that they could introduce you to. Love always seems to find people when they let go looking for it. As for your family, your worth should not be measured by whether or not you have a partner. Let them know it offends and upsets you when they leave you out. They may not even realize what they are doing. When you do meet someone, take the time you need to see what it is that they want so that you don’t fall for someone who doesn’t share the same vision of the future. Ask questions in a way that provides space for openness, honesty and vulnerability. If you don’t hear what you want to hear, ask yourself if it’s a deal breaker or if you can bend with the wind. When it comes to introducing someone to the family, make sure you’ve had the big conversations first. What do they see for their future in the next five years? Is a family in the mix? Marriage? Living together? What does it look like? Are they career-oriented? Do they expect their partner to be? What are the dynamics? Relationships are a series of compromises, but finding out where you stand with your partner is important before you bring your family in the mix. In the meantime, enjoy your friends and build for yourself a life that brings you contentment. A partner will then be icing on the cake.
Please send your questions to Natalie Bencivenga to
asknatalieadvice@gmail.com.
Check out her radio show every Saturday from 2-5pm EST on KDKA Radio 1020AM, 100.1FM, stream it on the
Audacy app or at www.kdkaradio.com
Watch her award-winning video series with Pennsylvania Capital Star, Facts Over Fear: www.penncapital-star.com
Follow Natalie on Instagram @NatalieBencivenga
and on TikTok @NatalieBencivenga