DEAR NATALIE: My fiancé’s ex-wife still has a key to his house and uses it whenever she feels like it. I recently moved in with my fiancé, and last week his ex-wife let herself in while I was home alone because she “needed a file.” He says it’s not a big deal because they co-parent peacefully, but I feel like a guest in my own home. We have plans to get married this fall, and I am worried she will still expect this level of freedom once I am his wife. Is this harmless co-parenting, or a red flag the size of a divorce decree? —NO KEYS, PLEASE
DEAR NO KEYS, PLEASE: You need to put your foot down on this issue immediately. This is not her house anymore, and there have to be boundaries set. It’s nice that they get along well, and I can understand his desire to keep the peace, but he also needs to recognize that the relationship has to shift in order to move forward. He needs to ask her for his key back. If she asks why, he can simply say that since he’s getting married, it’s a bit weird and awkward for you. There is truly no reason for her to have a key at this point, anyway, so he might as well just do it now. Happy wife, happy life, right? Hopefully he’s figured that out this second time around.
DEAR NATALIE: My partner of 11 years and I are currently in a good place. We went through a rough patch over the summer, and I became pretty close to his best friend during our separation. Nothing happened, but we talked constantly—and still do. We have chemistry that feels impossible to ignore at this point. What do I do with feelings that threaten to blow up everything, especially now that I’m back in a good place with my partner?�—CONFUSED BY LOVE
DEAR CONFUSED BY LOVE: Are you in a good place or do you think you were in a good place in the absence of fighting? Is this just the lull between battles with yourself or with him? While you might be going through this existential crisis, your partner’s friend might just be thinking this is all in good fun. Don’t assume he’s on the same level of emotional connection. Talk to him about how you feel. If he doesn’t have these feelings, then you need to cool it. If he does have these feelings, then you both need to decide whether you want to blow up a relationship of more than a decade and whether he wants to ruin a friendship. Either way, this probably isn’t about his friend but about you wanting to escape your reality in some aspect. Ask yourself what is missing in your relationships. If you can work on repairing it, then do that. Otherwise, it isn’t fair to keep your partner on the line.
Please send your questions to Natalie Bencivenga to
asknatalieadvice@gmail.com.
Watch her NEW video series with Pennsylvania Capital Star, Week in Focus: www.penncapital-star.com
Follow Natalie on Instagram and TikTok @NatalieBencivenga
Subscribe to her newsletter on Substack: Facts Over Fear