DEAR SOMEONE ELSE’S MOM: Halloween has always been a big deal in our family. My mom and dad would even switch off taking us around for trick or treating so they were both able to enjoy some of the fun too, and on the weekend closest to the holiday, they would host a big family and friends Halloween party. Everyone looked forward to it.
Advertisement
My sister is married to a man who was raised in a Fundamentalist Christian tradition, which she decided to embrace when they got married.
Her son from her first marriage was a highschooler by the time she and her second husband got together. But her current husband has his own children, who are tweeners. All their friends and their cousins trick or treat, but they are forbidden to. Yet when my sister was married to the father of her son, they were as into the fun of Halloween as the rest of our family.
How they choose to raise their children is their business, but my sister has started going on about how evil and anti-Christian we are for letting our children go trick or treating and celebrating what they call a satanic holiday.
Last time they were over to my house, she started telling our whole family, including the youngest, that to celebrate Halloween is to give in to and help spread evil.
I sometimes cannot believe she is so judgey and preachy, as that is not at all how we were raised, or how she used to be.
What she and her husband do with the kids they’re raising is their business, but why does she feel the need to tell everyone else what’s right or wrong for them? --- NEED MY SISTER TO JUDGE LESS
DEAR NEED MY SISTER TO JUDGE LESS: The “zeal of the convert” often takes those who knew them before their conversion by surprise, and it often requires adjustments by all parties.
At this point, your sister may feel she has an obligation to share, if not impose, her more recently espoused beliefs on others. Hence, the zeal.
While it’s not particularly likely to change her or her husband’s point-of-view, I think you wouldn’t be out of line to remind her that just as you respect her beliefs and choices, you expect her to extend that same curtesy to yours. Your civilly pushing back might at least serve to remind her that her way is not the only way, and that what works for her isn’t necessarily right, or even appropriate, for everyone else.