DEAR MISS MANNERS: When I host a dinner party and a guest presents me with a bottle of wine upon arrival, am I to assume this is a gift for later, or an offering for the dinner that evening?
Advertisement
Do I open it and present it as a beverage option along with the wine(s) I've selected for the meal, or do I set it to the side for a future use?
GENTLE READER: Time was, bringing a bottle of wine to a dinner party was considered somewhat insulting, as if the guest could not count on the host to serve a decent wine.
For all Miss Manners knows, that may still motivate some guests, although the practice has become common to the point of being unexceptionable.
Nevertheless, it should be considered a present and not a contribution to the meal. It may not be a good choice with the food being served, for one thing. And typically, people bring one bottle -- which is fine for a present, but may not be enough to serve the number of guests.
So the answer is that you may serve it if you like, but are not obligated to do so -- in which case, add to your thanks that you will look forward to enjoying it later.