DEAR MISS MANNERS: Last summer, I attended a barbecue with my husband’s co-workers and their families. I was introduced to a co-worker’s wife, who was wearing a T-shirt commemorating her close relative’s untimely death a year prior. My husband had told me what happened at the time, and how devastating it was to her and the rest of the family.
Advertisement
I am always careful to express condolences, but this time I was at a loss and ended up saying nothing. There were a number of reasons for this: I had never met the woman before, for one (I barely even know her husband), and the event was a casual and happy one, during which she and I only spoke briefly. And while I don't feel that my husband crossed any lines in telling me what she'd gone through, I think it would have been odd for a stranger to comment on her personal tragedy out of the blue.
But she was wearing a shirt with his name and his birth and death dates on it! Did I do the right thing? Or should I have briefly mentioned her relative and how sorry I was for her loss?
She and her husband are such lovely people; I hope I didn’t drop the ball.
GENTLE READER: T-shirt messages do not always convey immediate, mandatory instructions. Miss Manners has noticed that declarations such as “Kiss me, I’m Irish” (or "Italian" or whatever) have largely disappeared, perhaps because the wearers found they did not actually want strangers to comply.
A year after the tragedy, this woman might have just grabbed the shirt because it was handy. Commenting on it, or not, was up to your discretion.
However, Miss Manners will take this opportunity to once again remind her readers why condolence letters are so important. Having formally expressed sympathies at the time the tragedy occurred, one can avoid the awkwardness of bringing it up later in a more cheerful setting. But as you are careful about expressing condolences, Miss Manners assumes that your husband already sent such a letter.