DEAR MISS MANNERS: I attended a bridal shower where the bride-to-be asked for “no gifts, please.” Half the attendees showed up with gifts anyway, and the ones who honored her request and didn’t bring a gift were left to feel cheap.
Advertisement
It was awkward for everyone, including the bride-to-be, who wasn’t sure if she should open the gifts or not. What should she have done?
GENTLE READER: This is why Miss Manners keeps rejecting this frank and seemingly simple way of avoiding receiving presents: It doesn’t work.
Some people simply ignore it. Others interpret it as a coy prompt to be sure to give presents, or as a request for cash instead of goods.
It creates a burden on the gift recipient, who must then protect the guests who respected her wish from feeling that they were in error.
The bride should absolutely not have opened the presents in front of them. She should have briefly thanked the donors, put the unopened packages aside, and written her thanks after opening them privately.
But doesn’t anyone realize that, by definition, showers feature presents? So do birthday parties. Surely this accounts for the problem guests have with these gift bans. Can’t friends gather without applying those labels?