DEAR DR. FOX: I appreciate all your warnings about anti-flea and -tick insecticides in pet collars posing health risks to dogs and cats, and to any family members who pet them.
Advertisement
I am especially concerned about the chemical TCVP. According to a 2021 article on InvestigateMidwest.org, a "study by the Obama administration, in late 2016, had found that children are exposed to TCVP at such high levels in the collars that they are at risk of delayed mental development, lowered IQ scores and increased chances of autism and attention disorders."
Why isn’t more being done to take these poisons off the market? There are safer alternatives available. -- R.S. Minneapolis
DEAR R.S.: Many thanks for alerting readers to this issue. TCVP -- short for tetrachlorvinphos -- is a dangerous organophosphate insecticide used in pet flea collars. The Environmental Protection Agency made the decision in 2022 to ban TCVP, but reversed that decision in 2023 to scathing criticism.
These insecticides being given by veterinarians and sold in stores across the U.S. affect the developmental cycles, reproductive and nervous systems of ticks, fleas and other nontarget insects, so it should be no surprise to see similar effects on other life forms, including us.
The ecological impact of these insecticides, widely used by Big Ag and livestock keepers around the world, is catastrophic. They decimate the insect species and communities that keep the fabric of life together. Consequently, insect eaters -- such as birds, reptiles and amphibians -- are dying from starvation or, with weakened immune systems, succumbing to obliterating diseases.
I recently learned that short- and long-chain PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, also known as "forever chemicals") have been detected in some pesticides given to pets, notably Frontline Plus and Seresto collars. These chemicals are known to harm the immune system, weaken the antibody response to vaccinations and increase the risk of infectious disease. (See the study "Invited Perspective: The Far Reach of PFAS -- Inert Ingredients and Adjuvants in Pesticide Formulations" by Neha Sehgal et al., published in Environmental Health Perspectives, 2024.)
In addition, fipronil was one of the most prevalent contaminants in nearly 500 streams across five regions of the United States. (See the study "Forever Pesticides: A Growing Source of PFAS Contamination in the Environment" by Nathan Donley et al., published in Environmental Health Perspectives, 2024.)
The Natural Resources Defense Council is now suing the EPA to at least get the impregnated flea collars -- that put children, as well as companion animals, at risk -- off the market. For details, see: nrdc.org/bio/miriam-rotkin-ellman/no-more-poisonous-pets-epas-delay-flea-collars-threatens-our-kids.
All responsible veterinarians should not pander to owner convenience by prescribing toxic anti-flea and other antiparasitic medications without evident need, and certainly not as a “prevention.” This profit-driven Big Pharma ideology of regular preventive treatments is as absurd as taking aspirin in case one gets a headache or antibiotics to prevent some future infection.
Dogs and cats with fleas and ticks can be safely treated with alternative products, as detailed on my website: drfoxonehealth.com/post/preventing-fleas-ticks-and-mosquitoes. Safe and effective flea and tick repellants and oral supplements that boost resistance to these ectoparasites, and that also should be part of treating dogs and cats with mange mite and fungal skin infections, are available at earthanimal.com and core-pet.com.
SNAIL’S-PACE GOVERNMENT FOOD ADDITIVE REGULATION
Leaving a long trail of slime behind, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration is finally considering a ban on food dye Red No. 3. The agency has been reviewing a petition to ban the colorant since 2022.
The petroleum-based dye has been used for more than 50 years in thousands of products including candy, snack foods and sodas. It is one of several coal-tar derived azo dyes widely used in pet foods. When present in cat treats, Red No. 3 may trigger feline hyperesthesia, even seizures.
My book “Not Fit for a Dog: The Truth About Manufactured Cat and Dog Foods,” co-authored by two other veterinarians, underscored that these food additives were considered carcinogenic by the European Food Safety Authority and called for better oversight and restrictions. That was in 2009!
No veterinarian will deny that many of the dogs and cats they see develop cancer, and that is not because they are simply living longer. The longer our companion animals live, the more they are exposed to DNA-damaging chemicals in their food and environments, as are we. Azo dyes have no place in our foods, especially children’s cereals (along with sugar and high-fructose corn syrup), or in pet foods.
(Send all mail to animaldocfox@gmail.com or to Dr. Michael Fox in care of Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. The volume of mail received prohibits personal replies, but questions and comments of general interest will be discussed in future columns.
Visit Dr. Fox’s website at DrFoxOneHealth.com.)