It's not unusual for parents to help their adult children, even if it means making a financial sacrifice. A 2024 Financial Independence Survey by Bankrate, a consumer financial services company, reported that 61% of parents or guardians "are currently sacrificing, or have sacrificed, financially to provide assistance to their adult children" (tinyurl.com/56rrubkk).
Advertisement
What if one child needs more help than another?
That's the question a reader asked via email recently: "I'm hoping you have some advice for seniors with assets on how to navigate sharing with and leaving those assets to two children with vastly different needs." The reader said that one child is self-sufficient, while the other works at a low-paying job and cannot afford to rent a place.
"How do we best use our resources ... to help the child who needs help without alienating the other one?" the reader wrote.
This challenge doesn't have a simple solution. There are a number of factors to consider.
Some advisers feel that unequal treatment can be a necessity but caution about creating dependency.
"For parents of adult children, it's ... OK to consider uneven spending when a child faces hard times," said Chris Warren in the Synchrony article "When Uneven Spending on Your Kids Is Right" (tinyurl.com/4djv53de). "But all financial professionals caution against allowing an adult child's short-term financial need to become long-term financial dependency."
Will other siblings suffer? Psychologist Jeffrey Bernstein, Ph.D., an author of seven books, wrote on the Psychology Today website: "Parents naturally want to help their struggling child, but this can create an imbalance where the needs of other siblings are overlooked" (tinyurl.com/ycykey72).
Should parents worry about imbalance or negative emotions?
"The impact on siblings of struggling adult children may be hidden or palpable," explained Bernstein. "Yet I repeatedly see these siblings struggle with resentment, jealousy, and stress."
In my personal experience working with high-net-worth families over three decades, I can tell you there is no simple answer about how to handle this situation, for good reason: Each family has its own "culture." Some are open about finances; some are not. Some teach their children that they are all equal in the eyes of the parents. Some encourage independence, while others encourage the opposite. Some teach that life is full of challenges that need to be overcome; others see challenges as unfair barriers to happiness.
Family dynamics will dictate interactions and outcomes.
Given that perspective, the real answer to the reader's question is to start with a self-assessment. Explore your own family culture. What are the standards you live by?
Consider this: If you were in the position of the child who couldn't pay his rent, how would you handle that? If you would seek help from your parents for yourself and expect equal financial support for your sibling, there is your answer. That puts your family culture in perspective.
Further, if you thought your sibling would feel an unequal arrangement would be unfair, how would you handle that?
At what point would you consider your parents' finances, specifically the financial sacrifices they make for their children? Would you feel their sacrifices are unfair to them?
My own view is that a retired couple can compromise their own financial safety by creating a fairness test when a child calls for help. My view is simple: Solve one problem at a time.
First, remember that you need to support yourself in retirement; you do not want to become dependent on someone else (your children, for example) in retirement.
Then, focus on the financially strapped child by helping him get work, offering rent-free shelter or lending money for rent payments under a note with interest. (If you lend money to buy a house, secure the debt with a mortgage.) Have your estate documents provide that the child's potential future inheritance be reduced by any outstanding debt.
Once that is settled, then and only then consider if your resolution created a second problem to solve: "fairness between siblings." Solve one problem at a time.
DISTRIBUTED BY ANDREWS MCMEEL SYNDICATION