Kimberly Carpenter received a complimentary text recently from a dear friend.
Advertisement
“Congratulations on running the whole country. Good for you guys!” her friend wrote.
She was referring to Republican vice-presidential nominee J.D. Vance’s disparaging comments about “childless cat ladies” taking over the country. Carpenter, who works in insurance operations in St. Louis, is childless and a proud cat owner. Her immediate response was to laugh at Vance’s idiotic commentary, but she also found it deeply hurtful.
CNN reported that Vance has a long history of offensive commentary about people without children. He’s called Democratic leaders “childless sociopaths” who “don’t have a direct stake in this country.” While running for senator in 2021, his campaign sent fundraising emails referring to the “radical childless leaders in this country.” This was after his appearance on “Tucker Carlson Tonight,” during which he said, “We are effectively run in this country via the Democrats, via our corporate oligarchs, by a bunch of childless cat ladies who are miserable at their own lives and the choices that they’ve made and so they want to make the rest of the country miserable, too.”
He has since tried to back off the comments, which have elicited the ire of millions of potential voters, including typically nonpolitical celebrities like Jennifer Aniston. In a recent interview with Megyn Kelly, he said he was referring to Democrats as “anti-family,” adding that he doesn’t have anything against cats.
Vance may not have anything against cats, but he has a serious problem with women. His worldview bases the value of a woman on her ability and desire to reproduce. Vance, who converted to Catholicism, may be appealing to a base that shares the ideology that women belong at home raising children -- but this extreme view is far removed from the reality and values of most people.
All of us know someone who is childless -- either by choice or circumstance. Women who struggle with infertility or those who have not met the right partners or those who want to dedicate their lives to careers and communities are no less valuable or worthy than any parent.
Carpenter says it’s outrageous to suggest she isn’t invested in the future or in other children’s lives because they are not her own.
“I care about what this world is like for all of them,” she said. Her sentiments were shared by several other childless women I spoke to about Vance’s comments.
Hollie Brubaker, a television producer, made an independent film about her family’s journey with infertility. She spent two years on medications trying to conceive. Eventually, she and her husband decided their lives were full and complete without raising their own children. They love their nieces and nephews, and Brubaker is the emergency contact for her best friend’s kids.
“I have children in my life, and I am helping support other people (as they) raise their children,” she said. Moreover, she realized that she contributes a lot to her community and society regardless of her ability to reproduce.
Tracy Bednarick-Humes, an educational administrator, said Vance’s remarks reflect the rising movement in the government controlling how and when women should reproduce, like the abortion bans in place in many states after the Supreme Court overturned the protections of Roe v. Wade.
The bigger issue is about how women should lead their lives and who should control their decisions.
Julie Bauman, who works in project management and runs an animal rescue program, points out that childless people pay taxes that contribute to public schools. She said she is insulted that she even has to justify her worth in the world in light of Vance’s appalling, repeated attacks on the childless. She also wonders if the insults he lobs at women also apply to the countless childless men -- like George Washington -- who have led this country.
Dana Watkins Mullins, who works as a massage therapist, is as deeply invested in her community and the world as any mother.
“I’m not breeding stock,” she said. “I do a lot in my community ... I think me not having kids is one of the least selfish things I could have done.”
Elaine Vydra, who works in digital marketing, agrees: “For me, the more selfish thing would be having a child to make other people happy.”
Vydra had read Vance’s book, "Hillbilly Elegy," years ago, and said she found parts of his story -- where he describes overcoming a difficult childhood -- interesting, and that she had empathy for his struggles. So it was even more disappointing that he would make such harsh judgments about childless women and show a complete lack of empathy for others’ circumstances.
Carpenter ended up responding to her friend’s text on behalf of all childless cat ladies: “I didn’t know our plans for world domination were going so well.”