DEAR MISS MANNERS: My sister has five kids. Four are lovely: They each have their own quirks, but have always been polite and helpful.
Advertisement
Her fifth child is a terror. He is now a teenager and he has severe food restriction issues, for which my sister refuses to get him consistent help.
My sister and I each host three family events per year, and we have lots of food restrictions in the group (pescatarian, no sugar, gluten free). I am always able to do something creative that hits all the restrictions, or I do easy side accommodations (e.g., gluten-free bread for some of the bruschetta).
Accommodating the teenager's restrictions is difficult. There can be no vegetables or herbs. Chicken fingers, pizza and plain meat are the only options. I make entirely separate meals that meet his limits for events, but I am still met with rudeness and anger.
We recently had this 15-year-old demand specific brands of hot dogs, buns and mustard. That meant I had to juggle two different hot dog orders, buns and condiments on a grill in 90-degree weather -- none of which were materially different (beef hot dogs, white buns, yellow mustard).
I was screamed at because the chips my sister brought were not put in the right place on the buffet: The teenager had to pass by a plate of vegetables to reach the chips, which caused a fit. Clearly this is an illness, but he also never says thank you, never offers to help, and is aggressively rude.
I feel the need to have a stern talk with the kid next time he is rude with me. I wasn't born with a saddle on my back, and this kid wasn't born with spurs to ride me. Is it OK to give a 15-year-old the straight feedback that he is being rude?
GENTLE READER: Since you are aware it is an illness, you might approach your sister before attempting a more radical approach: "I don't seem to be able to please Damian, but I don't want to risk angering him further by pointing that out. What methods have been successful for you?"
If she comes up empty and you want to try being more direct, Miss Manners suggests you take the boy aside and kindly say, "This may work in your house, but it will not in mine. I'm afraid that when you are here, as long as we are meeting your medical restrictions, you will eat what we offer in whatever manner it is laid out. A vegetable never scared a donkey away from riding it."
Perhaps Miss Manners had better leave the folksy proverbs to you.