DEAR MISS MANNERS: Regardless of anyone's feelings on the matter, the popularity of giving children unique or unusual names is continuing. So what is a reasonable person to do when the name as written is pronounced differently than phonetics would allow?
Advertisement
For example, I recently came across a "Courtneigh." Reading this, it would be pronounced "Court-nay," but when I did that, I was corrected and told it should be "Court-knee."
I had one little girl the other day whose name was written "Mia," which is not unusual. But when I called for Mia, an angry mother huffily informed me that her name is pronounced "Maya," like the ancient civilization. There was another child with the seemingly normal name "Dominique." Except this child was a boy, and I was told to pronounce his name "Dominic."
I want to be welcoming to all, but how should I act when parents can't seem to spell? My own name is uncommon, but at least pronounceable.
GENTLE READER: Your annoyance is nothing compared to what those children will have to go through. Having an unusual name means a lifetime of spelling and pronouncing it for other people.
Parents may have good reasons for conferring such names anyway -- honoring a person or a heritage, for example. Or the desire for something distinctive (although it is odd how often names that seemed unique turn out to be part of a fad).
Or perhaps they just can't spell.
In any case, Miss Manners expects people to make a good-faith effort to learn how others want to be addressed. And she requires an equal good-faith effort from the bestowers and holders of these names when patiently explaining those preferences to others -- and ignoring mistakes that are not likely to be repeated.