DEAR MISS MANNERS: Over the last two years, I have been making incremental changes to lead a more eco-friendly lifestyle. Is it rude to give eco-friendly or reusable products to family and friends?
Advertisement
For example, my sister started a new job and I would like to give her a set of reusable utensils to eat her lunch with, rather than relying on her employer’s disposable plastic utensils. Is that OK? And for acquaintances, would goodie bags of, say, bamboo toothbrushes with powdered tooth soap be considered “too personal”?
I want to give gifts that align with my values without intruding on anyone's freedom to choose whatever products suit their lifestyles. How do I toe that line?
GENTLE READER: That is an excellent distinction to consider. Miss Manners has another: Are you considering presents that you believe the recipients will appreciate and enjoy, or is your motive to prod them into making changes they have no particular desire to make?
Presumably, those close to you know about your interest in achieving a more eco-friendly lifestyle. You seem tactful enough to have shared your beliefs without resorting to the popular -- and generally ineffective -- technique of shaming others. You will have been alert to any interest, ready to offer encouragement and advice.
But to give presents intended to satisfy you, without regard to pleasing them, violates the spirit of giving. Surely you can find items that respect your aims but do not bludgeon others into using -- or wasting -- them.