DEAR MISS MANNERS: I am a lifelong nonsmoker and naturally do not permit anyone to light up in my home or in my car. No exceptions. But when I’m a passenger in a vehicle driven by a friend who smokes, they will inevitably light up without asking if it’s OK.
Advertisement
They'll crack their window and blow the smoke out through the crack. Even so, the wisp of smoke from the still-burning cigarette quickly begins to fill the entire vehicle. It causes me to cough and rub my burning eyes. The friend will usually notice, sometimes offering a “sorry” and will perhaps extinguish their cigarette a minute sooner.
What is my best option, other than not getting in the car at all with a driver who smokes? Would it be rude for me to politely ask them to refrain from smoking until we reach our destination?
Yes, it’s their vehicle, their rules. But the health of my lungs should also matter.
GENTLE READER: In a more general form, yours is one of the principal etiquette questions of our day. But that question is often, to Miss Manners’ thinking, misstated.
Anyone with a serious medical condition understandably asks, "Whose need is greater?" And, in extreme situations, basic decency demands aiding those in need.
For more everyday situations, the proper question is, "How much can a guest reasonably impose upon a host?" The answer will depend on the closeness of the friendship and the extent, and frequency, of the imposition.
Used wisely, with a friend (not a mere acquaintance), there is an alternative to always declining a ride: You can decline with the explanation that even a little smoke bothers you and you do not want to impose. The driver can then decide whether to issue a second invitation, knowing that doing so is agreeing to more stringent conditions.