DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I’m impressed with the amount of nuance and content you can get from even the most anxious and overthinky emails. Today though, I need your help with something: how do I let someone go?
Advertisement
I had been interested someone who helped me make an emotional breakthrough when it came to dating; unfortunately, she isn’t interested in me and I’m not much interested in her anymore to be honest.
However, I’m having trouble moving on. My heart still flutters when I hear her voice or see her. I sent her a text basically saying “no hard feelings, just fine with being coworkers” and I want to leave it at that whether she answers or not. But it’s hard. I’ve made a lot of progress this year and I intend to keep it going. There’s this cute bartender at the tavern I go to, and I intend to get to know her. But I need to let this woman go first.
I want to move on. I want to see someone who actually loves me and cares about me and have a fulfilling relationship with. Not be some orbiter for someone who isn’t that into me in the first place.
How do I let go Doc? How do I move forward?
Make Like Elsa
DEAR MAKE LIKE ELSA: Hold up, MLE. Let’s leave the “how do I let go and move on” aside for a second because you have a pretty significant contradiction in your letter right at the jump. I mean, it’s kinda hard to square “I’m not much interested in her, to be honest” and “My heart still flutters when I hear her voice or see her.” Call me crazy, but that doesn’t exactly sound like “I’m not that interested in her, either”. The conflict between those two statements makes me wonder if you’re actually less interested in pursuing something with her or if you’re trying to convince someone that you are. And I’m not sure if you’re trying to convince me, her or you.
Now, functionally speaking, my advice is going to be the same: it’s going to take time, it’s going to require that you accept that this just didn’t work and that’s ok, and there’s going to be a period of acknowledging that you feel a little sad or disappointed that things didn’t work. You’ll want to make sure that you don’t wallow, and it’ll be good to stay busy and stay social, especially if you’re prone to over-thinking or getting lost in your own head. Otherwise, you end up running the risk of isolating yourself and just ruminating over the pain, like picking at a scab over and over again. Better to engage with your friends and remind yourself that even if this didn’t work, you’re not alone, nor unloved, and that life not only goes on, but so does joy and hope.
But even if the advice is going to be the same, it’s going to be important for you to really be honest with yourself about how you’re feeling and what you’re feeling. I can understand wanting to be over someone, just as I can understand wanting to be cool with things or that being rejected like that doesn’t hurt. I can even understand wanting to be mature about things and wanting to move through the sting of it all and get to acceptance as soon as you can. But that doesn’t mean that the pain don’t hurt, and pretending that you don’t feel it isn’t the same as not feeling it. You can – and should – be honest with yourself about what you’re feeling and why, even if you wish you were feeling another way.
I realize that it seems a bit “oooh, let’s sit down and process”, but acknowledging and respecting those feelings is important. When you try to force yourself to not feel in the name of being “the bigger man” or “being mature about it” or whatnot, you make it that much harder to actually get over someone. All you’re doing is kicking the catharsis down the road and taking that much longer to get over them. Speaking from personal experience: trying to not feel what you feel and not being honest with yourself about what you feel has a tendency to backfire, messily and all over the place. You convince yourself that everything’s cool, that you don’t feel a stab when you see her or hear her voice or read her name on something, but all you’re doing is shoving those feelings into a container with the label “Warning: contents under pressure”. Then something is going to puncture that container – it always does – and now you’re dealing with Inconvenient Feelings 2: The Secret of the Ooze.
So maybe take a little bit of time to say “ok, this sucks, I’m disappointed in how this turned out and sad that she doesn’t like me the way I like her. I would’ve liked things to be different, but they aren’t.” You’re clearly feeling those things, and it does you no good to pretend that you aren’t. It doesn’t speed things along, it doesn’t make you stronger emotionally, it just means you have to deal with it twice, and the second time tends to suck more because you have to feel it all again. Better to just let yourself be deep in the feels for a bit, let them flow through you and pass you and then when you look backwards, you’ll see that it has left you and you’ll be in a better place overall.
In the meantime, however, I’d recommend that you take this as an opportunity to not make similar mistakes going forward. A lot of relationship success is about finding the right people and not putting yourself in positions where you’re signing up for unnecessary disappointment or frustration. Your coworker was one example; your bartender is another. To be blunt, flirting with the bartender is unlikely to ever lead anywhere, and I don’t think you’re in a place – either emotionally or skill-wise – where you’d be able to flirt for the sake of flirting but without investing in the outcome. Bartenders, especially attractive female bartenders, are often professionally nice and professionally flirty with the customers, especially customers who flirt with them. I think the odds of your overestimating her interest are high, as are the odds of your getting another unfortunate crush and another unfortunate. While I fully approve of moving on and continuing to meet and chat up other women, I think this person in particular would be a poor choice. Better to find someone who doesn’t have a financial incentive to seem interested and approachable while being unavailable. Otherwise, you run the risk of repeating the same mistakes and enduring the same heartache by watering yet another dead plant.
The last thing I would suggest is that going forward, if you want to avoid being an orbiter, remember that ultimately your outlook should be “are you worth my time?” not “what can I do to get your attention/ prove I’m worthy” and the like. Somebody can be hot and make your heart do flip-flops; that doesn’t make them right for you, nor does it make them worth your time. You want to remember that at the end of the day, you want someone who is worth pursuing, not someone who you feel like you have to fight for their time and attention. That means not investing in them until they’ve shown that they’re worth investing in… and part of that will entail their willingness to show that they have similar levels of interest. If they aren’t, then you haven’t wasted time by hanging around in hopes that things will change; you’ve shifted gears to letting the relationship be whatever level it will be and moving on to find someone who is worth your time and energy.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com