Frankie was racing down the small hill in the backyard when he yelped and lifted his hind leg close to his body.
Advertisement
The first time my 16-pound cotton ball of a pup yipped in pain and started limping, I rushed him to the vet. It turned out he has a luxating patella -- basically a trick knee.
I learned to pop his knee back into place when it slips out of the socket and give him an anti-inflammatory pill. Normally, he would be back to his goofy self in a couple of hours.
This time, Frankie didn’t bounce back.
I carried him around until it was time for his appointment. The vet held Frankie’s chicken-bone sized joint between his fingers and showed me how his tibia slid forward in a way it shouldn’t. Frankie had torn his cranial cruciate ligament (CCL), which connects the thigh bone to the shin bone -- the equivalent of the ACL in humans. It’s a fairly common injury in active dogs and certain breeds.
The vet said the knee could eventually recover on its own, but dogs typically had better long-term outcomes if they got a surgical repair. This knee surgery can cost anywhere from $2,500 to $5,000.
Given that I had spent my entire childhood uninsured, I never got insurance for Frankie. It seemed like a peculiar luxury to purchase health insurance for a dog when 26 million Americans are uninsured.
Maybe that was a bad decision.
Just like Frankie’s ligament, I was also torn. I didn’t want to subject him to an unnecessary surgery, not to mention a recovery that required weeks of inactivity. The operation's cost was also a concern: We are still paying for two children in college. But I also didn’t want him to develop painful arthritis or bone spurs later in life.
He was 6 at the time, and could live another decade.
I told the vet I would think it over.
Frankie is a Coton du Tulear, so I asked other owners of Cotons in a Facebook group if they had opted for surgery after a similar injury. Half of those who responded advised getting the surgery; the other half said to let it heal on its own. When I asked my dog-owning friends, half of them said their dogs had also torn their knee ligaments.
The CCL repair is the most common orthopedic surgery for dogs -- partly because dogs are living longer than in the past and partly because more pet owners have insurance, or are willing to pay for the surgery.
Frankie is my first dog, and I’ve already spent way more on him than I could have ever imagined spending on an animal -- from grooming to boarding to day camp to training to an endless supply of treats and toys.
For the next month, I tried every home remedy mentioned on Al Gore’s internet. I fed Frankie homemade bone broth and fresh chicken at each meal. I gave him glucosamine supplements. I used red light therapy on his knee. I massaged his limbs and carried him everywhere.
He was not averse to any of this. He was able to walk without pain, although his gait looked a little off. But during one of our short walks, I heard a clicking coming from his knee. Probably a meniscus tear, the internet informed me.
I called and scheduled Frankie’s surgery.
I was a wreck the day of the procedure. Afterward, the vet’s staff assured me it went well and sent me home with pages of post-surgical care notes. Frankie was groggy and whined in pain later that evening.
Maybe I had made a big mistake.
Friends assured me that the first week of recovery was the worst. Their dogs got substantially better week by week. I continued to pamper Frankie.
He watched DogTV videos on YouTube. I bought baby gates to contain him to a single room downstairs, and enrichment toys to keep his brain occupied.
I could never have anticipated how much attention and nurturing I could devote to a pet. To be honest, Frankie acts a lot more like a toddler than a dog. In a parallel universe -- where day care and college didn’t cost so much -- I’m sure we would have had more children. Instead, Frankie, who has no post-graduate plans, is my third child.
It’s been three months since he tore his knee. He’s running around the backyard again. He can hop up on the couch. I’ve kept up with his joint supplements, the fresh boiled chicken on top of his kibble and gentle stretching exercises in the morning.
Occasionally, I can still hear his knee click when we go for a walk, so I still wonder if the surgery will be worth it for him in the long run.
But knowing that I’ve done everything I can for him is absolutely worth it.