DEAR DR. NERDLOVE : I met this girl and she wanted casual and I didn’t know what I wanted. I was a virgin at the time and now she’s gone and I’m left wondering if I did something wrong.
Advertisement
I also regret not having sex with her more, I only did once because I told her I wanted a committed relationship and looking back, I wish I said something different. So my question is: what should I have done differently or better?
Hindsight Is 20/20
DEAR HINDSIGHT IS 20/20: You already answered your own question, HITT: you wish you’d had more sex and hadn’t been as insistent on a committed relationship. Well, there you go, glad I could help.
Honestly, whatever I tell you isn’t going to be that relevant without a flux capacitor or a big blue box. You were making the best decisions you could at the time, based on what you knew about yourself at the time. Which, admittedly, wasn’t much, but that’s entirely forgivable; you were inexperienced and didn’t know what you wanted at the time. It sounds like you defaulted to what you thought you should want – a committed relationship – which is understandable. That’s something we’re told over and over again that we should ultimately be striving for. But being told that’s what we should want isn’t the same as being what we actually want. And sometimes what we think we want turns out to be wrong; we actually wanted something different, we just didn’t realize it at the time.
Well, now you know more about yourself and what you want, and in the future, you’ll make different decisions. Which is good, because your next relationship is also going to be different. And so will the one after that. And the one after that. You may even find that you go back and forth between wanting one thing and then another. That’s fine. What you want is going to be as much about who you are at the time and where you are in your life. You aren’t the same person from one year to the next, so why should the kind of relationship you’re looking for be any different?
Now what you could do better? That one’s easy, and in this case, something I have a lot of personal experience with. The thing you could’ve done better is to not try to push for a committed relationship with someone who is only looking for casual.
Now, again, I’m giving you a pass here: you were inexperienced and this is something that you tend to learn through doing. But I have been there and done that. I dated a girl I thought was perfect for me… except for the part where she just wanted something casual and I wanted a girlfriend. I agreed to keep things casual, but in my head I thought “…but I bet I can change your mind”. And, to absolutely nobody’s surprise, that relationship ended and I was devastated. It would likely have ended anyway, but it wasn’t helped by the fact that I heard “casual” and thought “yeah, whatever” and tried to make a committed relationship happen anyway.
The moral of this story: don’t agree to a relationship model you don’t actually want in hopes of changing things. It’s one thing if you say “OK, I can do casual, but I’d like to talk about this down the line”. It’s another to think that you’re going to be able to change someone’s mind, especially without talking about it with them.
However, I’ll give an addendum to that: don’t say what you think they want to hear just because you want to get laid. That’s not going to serve you any better. If you legitimately didn’t want a casual relationship, agreeing to it just so you could get her in bed another time or two before the inevitable break up wasn’t going to make things better. It would just add a different, unpleasant layer to the break up and likely leave you feeling bad – possibly worse – about the whole thing.
For now though? Take this as a learning opportunity for yourself. You know a bit more about who you are and what you want. If you don’t know what you want, then say that. It may be better to aim for lower-commitment relationships if you’re unsure; it’s generally easier to move from “casual” to “committed” than it is to go the other. At least, it’s easier to do so without triggering the end of the relationship, anyway.
Otherwise? Take this, learn from it, and apply it to the next time you date someone. You’ll still make mistakes – everyone does, because we’re all human – but they’ll be different ones, and you’ll have more experience to handle them.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com