DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: So I’ve come to learn a very painful lesson that we’ll not matter what I do I don’t belong anywhere really or with any community. I love making art but you’re not stereotypical artist of being queer, softboi, thin or androgynous so I don’t belong with that community. I’m Hispanic yet I’m not of swarthy complexion not fiery or spicy or can’t even dance so even I’m in my culture I feel like an outsider. Tabletop wargaming is one hobby I enjoy yet I’m neither odd quirky enough or socially awkward like people with at my store nor am I well, queer, which again is a community I don’t feel like I belong to. I enjoy going to the gym yet I feel like I don’t belong there because I’m quite introverted and not very hurrah gym bro with big bulging muscles again. I’m a huge metalhead yet at metal head yet when I go to metal concerts I feel like an outsider or a poser because I’m not tatted up to the max nor do I wear all black, wear patches or have piercings or wear black eyeliner. I love going to conventions yet I’ve never made a single cosplay in my life and once again I feel like an outsider there.
Advertisement
No matter where I go or what I do I just simply do not belong there no matter how much I try. I feel fake, forced, like a poser a weed among the garden of flowers. That saying of “God give me confidence of a mediocre white man” I think of myself “hey I know that guy” he’s me (just say he slightly, autistic and has a small penis to really emphasize his mediocrity).
Even then my therapist tells me to try out therapy groups or something like that with my issues which again I feel like I simply DO NOT BELONG there. Because I’m not traumatized or a victim of abuse which most of those groups are made of. I’m autistic yet I feel like I don’t belong in autistic therapy groups because I’m on the higher functioning compared to other people who have it worst off them so I’m going stick out for the worst reasons. That’s not even getting my crippling body image issues which I have suggested therapy groups but once again I don’t belong there because mostly women’s group so am already sticking out in the worst way possible and we’ll my body image issues come from essentially eating too much compared to most which involves anorexia. It would be like saying my tummy hurts in a support group of stage 3 stomach cancer patients.
So yeah even among “outliers” and “outsiders” I’m an outsider. It makes me feel so fake and like fraud and I hate that feeling so much, it’s lonely and isolating. I just want to belong somewhere, be among like-minded people without having to second guess myself or feeling like I stand out like a sore thumb. To be among people I can happily call my peers and my community and actually have it mean something. How do it? How do I belong somewhere and actually feel like I belong there?
Sincerely,
A Vulture Among Odd Ducks
DEAR A VULTURE AMONG ODD DUCKS: This is a self-created problem, VAOD, but not in the way you think. Your isolation is primarily caused by choice, rather than by circumstance. This is actually good news, in its way. Because your isolation is self-inflicted, it means that you’re able to fix it rather easily. But in order to do that, first you have to actually address the cause that’s leading to your isolation. And that’s where you’re getting things wrong. Until you actually address the underlying issue, you’re going to continue having issues like these. You may find, for example, that even if you stop isolating yourself from the world around you, that this issue will come up in other areas.
The problem here is one of intellectual fallacies and black and white thinking. You’re acting as though you need to be an extreme example of a particular group (or, more accurately, the stereotype of a particular group) in order to be part of a community… and honestly, that’s entirely about you and how you feel about yourself. You
Now, a lot of what you’re talking about are about how much you match a popular stereotype and treating that as whether you “deserve” to be part of the group – as though fitting into a particular look was a prerequisite. This would be true if, say, you were determined to join a group of posers who are more interested in the supposed aesthetics of a community instead of the substance, or signing up with a group of gatekeeping s--theads who want to pretend that they have some sort of ownership and authority over fandom. But you’re not. So I have to wonder why you’re focusing on the maximalist interpretation, where you have to be at the far edges of a group rather than realizing that part of the point of the community is the love of the thing that brings that community together.
Let’s take art, for example. The only requirement for entry to being an artist is… making art. Good art, bad art, marketable art, popular art, art that you couldn’t sell if your life depended on it… none of that matters. You make art? You’re an artist. Yeah, there’re lots of folks in art school who are all about the aesthetics and lifestyle of the aaaaaaahteeeest than making art, but that’s entirely different from, y’know, being an artist.
As someone who’s got a lot of creative friends – from comic artists to screen printers, writers, filmmakers, podcasters, photographers, makers, sculptors, fine artists, cosplayers and creatives all along the spectrum, I can tell you for a fact that they are as wide and as varied as you could want. Some of them are what you might call “softbois”, some are queer, some are gender-non-conforming… and many are standard-issue cisgendered hetero people that make up the majority of the population. Their gender, sexuality, neurotypicality or divergence all informed their art and the kind of art they made, sure… but none of it meant that they were or weren’t artists.
Back when I was doing a lot more drawing, I was part of a local group that would get together on Sundays at a coffeeshop downtown and just we’d just draw. We were a diverse bunch in terms of gender, lifestyle and presentation; some were goths, some were considerably more jock-like. Some were hipster-y, some were very stylish, some were very average and unremarkable in their style. Nobody was seen as “not being one of the group” because they were too butch or masc, too femme, too inked up (which, in Austin, takes some doing) or not inked enough. Nor, for that matter, was it a question of skill or talent. There were folks who are now superstar artists at Marvel and DC, or who went on to be lead artists at major game devs like Bioware, Bethesda and Arkane Austin. Some were decent as long as they used a LOT of references and crutches (me, we’re talking about me here), and some people who could barely draw stick figures.��Some of used physical media while others drew entirely digitally. Hell, not everyone drew. Some folks would paint or do watercolor or do stuff with Super Sculpey or Fimo. If 3D printers had existed at the time, I’m sure some would be using modeling stuff to print later. The important thing was that we all came together because we liked drawing and creating and hanging out with other people who liked to draw and create. That (and not being a screaming asshole) was all that was necessary to be part of the community.
Being a metalhead is very similar. One of the more unifying things about the metal community is that it’s pretty wide ranging. Get five metalheads in one room and you’re going to have six opinions and seven different examples of what a metalhead looks like. Not everyone’s going to be rocking mullets and battle vests any more than everyone’s going to be wearing corpse paint, dressing like a British leather daddy or like they just rolled out of a Ren Faire or Hall H, and not everyone’s expected to. Getting a bunch of patches and studs and putting together a battle vest isn’t a requirement, it’s just how some folks choose to express their fandom. ��(It is, however, fun as s--t and makes you look cool as hell.)
The ethos of the metal community (and also of punk, for that matter) is “you must be cool, because if you weren’t cool, you wouldn’t be here”.
(And for the record, that’s the official word from Henry f--kin’ Rollins)��It’s not about conformity, it’s about loving some f--king metal and rocking your face off.
The same goes for taking part in fandom or going to conventions. Cosplayers are a subset of fandom; they’re people who express their love for their fandom by way of bringing their fandom to life – by creating costumes and props, by embodying those characters via those costumes and props, or both; not every cosplayer is a maker and not every maker also cosplays. But you’re not required to cosplay in order to be part of the fan community or to go to cons; again, the ticket to entry is being a fan. If you want to be part of the cosplayer community, then yes, participating is part of it… but even then, there’re multiple ways of participating that aren’t making or wearing the costumes. You can be a photographer, run gallery sites, organize events at cons, be someone’s handler/assistant/brute squad and so on.
But to be a fan doesn’t mean you have to be part of a particular subgroup any more than you have to follow a particular style or live a particular way. One of the best compliments I’ve ever gotten was from a friend who once asked me “If I kill you, do all the other nerds die?”, but if you were to see me out and about in my usual well-heeled-Metallica-roadie getup, you might be a bit surprised when I can bust out all the songs from the Rocky Horror Picture Show or pull the deep 80s cartoon cuts from off the top of my head. I’ve got my geek shibboleths, sure, but you have to be pretty observant to clock ‘em at a glance.
Nor, for that matter, does being a member of a particular community mean that you need to imitate the most vocal or visible examples of that community. Unless you’re trying to be a body builder or powerlifter, nobody at the gym is expecting you to be a ‘roidhead. And unless you’re going to a very specific kind of gym, most folks don’t want you to be one of those guys; they tend to be among the most obnoxious gym-goers around.
That same thing applies to, say, mental health. Yeah, you don’t want to, say, join a cancer support group when you don’t actually, y’know, have cancer, but you don’t have to be just this side of getting 5150’d to take part in group therapy. Part of the whole point of group therapy is realizing that you’re not alone, that lots of people have similar issues to yours and you’re all wrestling with similar demons and knowing this helps. The people who know the name of your demon can tell you how to handle it and vice versa.
You’re also buying into some of the same thinking that actually isolates folks who have issues similar to yours. Those body image issues you’re saying you don’t want to go to therapy for because most of the groups would be full of women? Well, the whole reason why they’re mostly full of women is because a lot of men are afraid to admit they have body image issues. This despite the fact that eating disorders and body dysmorphia is on the rise in men. It’s that feeling of “I’m afraid admit it because I’m not like the others” that causes men to isolate themselves and not only continue to perpetuate the stigma, but keeps people like you from getting the help that they both need and deserve.
Now, if most of the groups around you are specifically for anorexia, then yes, those groups may not be a good fit. But disordered eating is disordered eating; the details may vary, but the root causes tend to be the same. You may have a different relationship to food from someone who’s bulimic, but that doesn’t mean that you don’t have a problem or that you don’t need support.
Another issue is that you’re falling for a form of the Fallacy of Relative Privation – the idea that your problems don’t matter because there’re other people with worse, bigger problems. Weirdly, however, the fact that someone in the world has bowel cancer doesn’t make another person’s gluten intolerance less of a problem or cause a third person’s IBS to be easier to live with. There are other neurodivergent people whose ADHD hits a lot harder than mine; that doesn’t mean that mine doesn’t and hasn’t negatively impacted my life.
But you know what happens if you go to an autism support group, despite not struggling as much as some in that group? You get support. You get access to resources, insight and suggestions on how to deal with issues related to being autistic – things that will make your life better. And if someone’s autism is more profound than yours… well, over the course of your time in that group you might be the one providing insight and advice to them.
Now here is an important question, and one that I think will really drive things home: would you gatekeep other people from saying that they’re part of those communities? Are you going to stand up and say that a friend of yours shouldn’t be going to metal concerts because they’re not tatted up enough or don’t have enough black band tees? Are you going to tell someone that they can’t call themselves an otaku because they don’t have a Jujitsu Kaisen shrine or can’t name every voice actor (dub or sub) from Demon Slayer? Do you seriously believe that someone can’t be a Critter because they haven’t been to GenCon or Emerald City or SDCC dressed as Percy or Fresh Cut Grass? Would you tell people not to call themselves an artist because they don’t look like they live in a converted Bronx warehouse and dress like Goodwill exploded all over them?
I’m going to guess that no, no you wouldn’t. You wouldn’t insist that they stand out too much or that they’re not “true” members of that community just because they don’t march in lock-step with everyone else.
So why in the 108 f--king names of God are you holding yourself to such an absurd standard? If you can see how other people – people who aren’t softbois or so many piercings that they’re more metal than man or what-have-you – can be part of a community without being a carbon copy clone of everyone else, then why are you doing that to yourself? Why does everyone else get grace that you aren’t willing to give yourself?
Sit with that for a moment. Really think about it. What is it about you that means that you aren’t allowed the same lenience, the same beneficence that you would grant to others? Why are you forbidden from entry when others who are like you are permitted? And why are you doing this to yourself?
This isn’t about not fitting in. This is about not letting yourself fit in because you think that there’s some purity test that you aren’t going to pass or that you’re not a “true” whatever. Well funny thing about “true” vs. “fake” fans or “true” vs. “fake” artists or “true” and “fake” neurodivergent people: the folks most concerned with “true” vs. “fake” tend to be the insecure s--tbags who think that the answer to their exclusion is to exclude others because they’ve never dealt with their own hurt. Those purity tests don’t actually exist and when they do, then f--k the testers; go find a better class of people to hang out with and let the losers wall themselves off until they suffocate and starve. The Sad Puppies, ‘gators, grognards, wannabe-SMOFS and all the rest can circlejerk themselves until they’re dehydrated while proclaiming themselves the true owners of whatever property; meanwhile everyone else will give them exactly the amount of consideration they deserve.
The way you fit in with a community is being part of that community and participating in it. You don’t need to participate in the exact same way as everyone else, nor should you. Your uniqueness and your relationship with the fandom, with the neurodiversity, with whatever, brings your own brand of specialness to that community. It may not look exactly the same as other people’s and that’s fine. Thriving communities aren’t some uniform soup where every ingredient has been homogenized and pureed and blended until they’re indistinguishable from one another. They’re a gumbo, full of many different ingredients that come together to make something bigger than the sum of their parts. If some group is insisting on perfect conformity as the price of entry, then find a better, classier group that isn’t so inbred.
Hell, you could even start your own. That’s how my Drinkin’ And Drawin’ group came about; one guy decided “hey it’d be nice if there were an opportunity for folks to hang out, make friends and make art” and by God he made it happen.
The same goes for finding support groups. The black-and-white, extremist thinking that the only groups that are valid are for the absolute worst-off only serves to isolate yourself from both community and assistance, and for no reason other than to spite yourself because f--k you, that’s why. That’s brain-meltingly, pants-on-head absurd. Stop cutting yourself off from the help you need just because you think someone else has it worse. You have problems. Support groups exist to provide support for people who have those problems. Pretending your problems aren’t really problems is just suffering for suffering’s sake, crucifying yourself for no reason other than “well someone else might have it worse than me”. Yes, someone absolutely does. And unless that person’s existence magically makes your problem vanish, then you’re still the exact sort of person that group exists to support. Your not going isn’t making things better for other people. You’re just making things harder for yourself, and for no reason other than misguided martyrdom. And trust me, the folks you think have it worse than you? They’re not begrudging you seeking support for your problems, any more than you would begrudge others for seeking help with theirs.
Stop holding yourself back. Find your support and find your people. You are artist enough. You are Hispanic enough. You are fan enough. You are autistic enough.
You. Are. Enough.
All will be well.
Bottom of Form
Bottom of Form
Bottom of Form
Bottom of Form
Top of Form
Bottom of Form
Top of Form
Bottom of Form
Top of Form
Bottom of Form
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com