DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I’m reaching out because I’m feeling incredibly confused and frustrated about my relationship, and I really need your perspective. I’m currently dating this stunningly beautiful girl, and I can’t help but wonder why on earth she’s with someone like me. When I look in the mirror, all I see is someone who isn’t physically attractive. I don’t have a gym body, I don’t have money, and honestly, my face isn’t anything special
Advertisement
I’ve tried using Tinder, which everyone seems to treat as the ultimate solution for finding attractive partners. People rave about how it opens doors to incredible connections and allows you to meet people who genuinely appeal to you. But for me, it’s been a complete disaster. I’ve never had any luck on that platform. Every time I swipe, I’m painfully aware that I’m not the type of person that most girls are looking for.
So here I am, with this girl who could have any guy she wants, and I can’t help but think: what does she see in me? Does she have a vision problem? Is she just looking for a charity case? Or is there something about me that I’m completely missing? I feel like a misfit in a world where physical attractiveness seems to be the only thing that matters, and it’s eating away at my self-esteem.
To be honest, I’ve even started to consider whether I should just end things with her. I mean, she’s so beautiful that I can’t shake the feeling that I’m somehow holding her back from being with someone who truly deserves her. It feels like I’m living in a fairy tale where I don’t belong, and I worry that I’m just a placeholder until she finds someone better. The thought of her being with someone else who matches her beauty and charm only adds to my anxiety.
I’m genuinely wrestling with all of this, and I’d love to hear your thoughts on how attraction works beyond physical appearance. Is there something deeper that I’m missing, or is this just a situation that’s doomed from the start? What really matters in the end when it comes to relationships?
Thanks in advance for your help. I really appreciate it.
Stand In Boyfriend
DEAR STAND IN BOYFRIEND: There’re three separate issues embedded in your letter, SIB, but they’re all twisted and tied around each other like horny snakes, creating a Gordian knot of insecurity. And while it’s probably better to cut the damn thing in half, I wouldn’t be me if I didn’t pick them apart a bit first.
So, let’s start with the face you see in the mirror. There’re a couple of things here. The first is actually fairly simple: you’re basing your judgment on your attractiveness on what other men have told you that women want, not what women necessarily are interested in. The qualities you mention – the gym body and money, in particular, are qualities that men tend to admire in other men. These are symbols of status and power to other men, things that other men want to have or to emulate… but not necessarily what women want.
In fact, if you ask women – and I mean literally ask the women in your life – I think you’d find very quickly that your bank account or take-home pay isn’t even in the top 10 of qualities that they’re looking for. The idea of “a man must have money” is a consideration in as much as that women want someone who isn’t going to be a drag on them than wanting Daddy Morebucks. Yes, there’re women out there who (supposedly) want men to be a walking ATM that spoils them and takes care of everything… but this is far more a product of social media than reality. You’ll see a lot of “want a rich man who’ll take care of me” videos on TikTok or whatnot, but those are selling a fantasy to men, not an actual significant population of the dating public. ��(This, incidentally, includes tradwife types; it’s rather telling that they tend to already come from money and are, in fact, running a business of their own, rather than just keeping house for their husband. It’s a fantasy at best, a con at worst.)
While there are genuine gold-diggers out there, they’re few, far between and very, very obvious about it, and you, specifically, are not likely to encounter them in the first place. There are far more women who really just want someone who is going to pull their weight and not be frivolous with money in ways that will make things harder. This is far less about “I want a partner who’s a provider” and more “I want someone who’s a responsible adult and isn’t going to sacrifice the rent check because he wanted a bigger TV”.
The same goes with “gym bods”. This is another area that’s a trivially simple belief to debunk. It just requires going outside and actually paying attention to the couples you see. Go to the park, the zoo or Costco, Target or WalMart on any given weekend and you will see couples all over the place… and significantly, many if not most of them aren’t going to look like they spend all their time pumping iron. Men are far more into the athlete look and what it says than women are. While yes, women have body types that they love – aesthetically or otherwise – what they’re attracted to can be as wide and varied as it is for men. If you can be attracted to someone who doesn’t look like Sydney Sweeney or an Instagram fitness influencer, it should be obvious that women can be too.
I would also point out that not thinking you’re attractive doesn’t mean that you objectively aren’t. A thing that guys rarely consider is that, quite simply, they’re not their own type. Not having facial features that you think are attractive doesn’t mean that you look like the Toxic Avenger; it just means that those aren’t necessarily features that you would think are hot. That’s very different from being objectively ugly. And as I’ve said over and over again: if I had a nickel for every guy who insists that he fell out of the Ugly Tree and hit every branch on the way down but in reality, mostly needed a better haircut and skin care routine, I’d be swimming through my money bin like Scrooge McDuck.
Seriously, go watch some Queer Eye and notice how a simple haircut and better fitting clothes can be transformative.
The next issue that you bring up is Tinder specifically and dating apps in general. I don’t know who told you that Tinder was this amazing place to make incredible connections, but they either were misled or delusional. Tinder’s never fully gotten away from its hook-up app origins and has always focused on a far shallower, split-second judgment rather than forming real connections. It’s always been a place where your ability to look good in photos (which is not the same thing as being physically attractive) is the primary concern. But it – and most dating apps in general – are designed to be frustrating. They are set up to encourage mindless and continual swiping, and your choices (and the choices of others) are constrained both by an algorithm and a user experience that’s intended to annoy you until you’re ready to pay money to be less annoyed. Think of dating apps as being akin to Candy Crush; you can play for free, but they’ve designed it in such a way that you are pushed to convert and buy their boosts to alleviate the frustration.
It’s also important to note that not only are there massive gender imbalances in the user base (approximately a 70/30 male/female split, depending on your source), but it also takes a VERY large number of swipes on average per match and a number of matches to get a date. So, part of the frustration is that there is a limited pool of potential partners overall and the expectation that it will be a quick turnaround from “sign up” to “get date” has always been more marketing hype than reality.
This is part of why I’ve been telling people to deprioritize the apps and focus on meeting people in person. If you’re going to use the apps, you want to do so deliberately, mindfully and with serious restrictions on how you use them.
Now all of this is to lay the groundwork about your real issue – the mistaken impressions and outright deceptions that are part of the insecurity you’re feeling. You’re experiencing these things, not because they’re objectively true, but because of things that play to your anxieties, deliberately and otherwise.
Now, let’s talk about your girlfriend. And rather than focus on the concerns that your insecurity is throwing your way, let’s focus on things that are concrete. Instead of absurd “what if’s” that only make sense if you are begging the question, let’s pay attention to what is most likely, most reasonable and actually comports with the real world.
Let’s start with an obvious one: yes, sometimes people will date someone they’re not attracted to simply because they are trying to have A Relationship. But this tends to be more male behavior rather than female behavior; guys who are picking someone because they are looking for the chance to have sex. Women who behave like this tend not to seek out placeholder relationships; they are more likely to stay in relationships that no longer work rather than to seek out someone they’re not into. Even the whole “cuffing season” schtick (which, quite frankly, I think is more media hype and memes than reality) is more about “find someone who’s good for the short term”, not “I will take what I can get”.
But then the question would be: why you? Why would someone pick you if you had no desirable qualities, even if you were a short-term partner by design? What, realistically, would be her motivation? And I do mean realistically; the idea that she’s so myopic that you look like an Impressionist painting rather than a person is absurd on its face. So too is the idea that she’s just pranking you or that she’s taken pity on you. I hate to tell you this but people – not women, people – don’t date people out of pity or for charity. If she chose you, she chose you for a reason, so what reason would that be if she didn’t actually like you and want to date you specifically? Again: is there something that a reasonable outside observer would agree is the case? Or is it more reasonable to say that this is your insecurity talking?
Here’s another thing to consider: what, if anything, about your girlfriend’s behavior would lead a reasonable outside observer to think that she doesn’t actually like you or motivate her to lie to you about wanting to date you? Leave aside your feelings about your attractiveness; that’s not evidence, that’s speculation. I am talking about her behavior, her actions, things that she has said and done. What reason would she have to date you besides wanting to date you, specifically?
Has she acted bored or disappointed when she’s been with you? Has she made comments about wanting better or more or things you don’t offer? Has she talked you down, compared you unfavorably to other men or said that she wished you were more like X person or Y person? With everything you know about her, has she ever done or said anything that would lead a reasonable person to think that she’s the sort of person who would engage in that sort of behavior in the first place, never mind with you specifically? ��And here’s the single, most important question: why don’t you trust your girlfriend? Has she said or done anything that a reasonable outside observer would think is deceptive or indicative that she’s using you? Or is this entirely down to your insecurity and your unwillingness to accept that this is exactly as it appears?
Here’s the thing: I think you’re so invested in your belief that you’re unattractive that you’re afraid to be wrong. You want to believe this is a trick because then you aren’t responsible for this relationship; if it ends, it was always going to end, not because you did something to hasten that ending. People are frequently afraid of success, because now they have something that they have to work at and maintain. They’re responsible for the outcome of their own choices and the dildo of consequences rarely arrives pre-lubricated. It’s much easier when failure is assured, especially if you can blame it on The Universe instead of having to acknowledge your own agency. Hope, after all, is a very scary thing when you’re not used to having it.
So at the end of the day, this comes down to whether you actually trust your girlfriend or not and whether you respect both her choices and her agency. The idea that you should break up with her “because you’re holding her back” is actually kind of insulting; it implies that you know better than she does and that her actual desires and choices mean less than what you think she should want. If you don’t trust her, then yes, you should break up with her. Not because she’s lying to you, but because that lack of trust is corrosive, and it’ll destroy the relationship anyway. It’s incredibly harmful when someone you love calls you a liar every time you say that you love them, and in time you quit fighting them over it because the pain just becomes too much.
But if you do that, then you also have to admit that you didn’t break up with her for the greater good, you did it because you couldn’t let yourself trust her or be happy with her. You snatched defeat from the jaws of victory because you wouldn’t accept that maybe this was exactly what it seemed and she actually cared for you because you’re you.
So maybe the relationship you need to focus on more is your relationship with yourself. This letter is precisely the reason why I bring up the Ru Paul quote over and over again: you don’t love yourself, and so you can’t accept that others love you. So perhaps what you need more than anything else is to learn to love yourself, so you can recognize and accept love when it’s freely given and not a trick.
So, were I you? I would stop questioning why your girlfriend is with you and start questioning why you can’t accept it. And that’s the sort of thing that’s best sorted on the therapist’s couch, not by pushing away people whose only crime is liking your company and finding their time with you to be enriching and pleasurable.
You’ve got a good thing here, and one that goes directly against your own bulls--t beliefs. Maybe you should lean into that instead of fighting against it. Sometimes stories really do have a happy ending. So hie thyself to the therapist’s office and do some couple’s counseling with yourself. It’ll make you much, much happier overall.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com