Ask Dr. Nerdlove

DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I’ve been seeing my girlfriend for the last six months. When we met, I thought she was too good to be true, and I couldn’t believe that she was interested in someone like me. We had so much in common and our connection was crazy intense. It felt like we could talk about anything and it seemed like we were sharing things with each other that we never shared with anyone else. I mean the deep, dark, personal stuff. I was thrilled that I found someone I could be this open with, like we really knew everything about each other.

That was until I found out she’s been lying to me about her past.

A few weeks ago, we were discussing our previous relationships (I know, I know, this was a mistake) and she started getting cagey about some of her exes. I didn’t think much about it until I was scrolling through Facebook and saw a guy who commented on one of her posts who she never mentioned before, but it seemed like he knew her pretty well. I wasn’t suspicious, I just was curious who he was, because I like getting to know more about what she was like before we met. Would we have liked each other if we met in high-school, you know, that sort of thing. It’s just cute “what if” stuff.

But that was before now. I asked her about him and she suddenly didn’t want to talk about him. At all. This was weird to me because we’d been open books about pretty much everything else. I’m not going to lie, I started getting worried and a little suspicious that she suddenly didn’t want to talk about him.

Naturally I feared the worst. It was like an itch I couldn’t get rid of; who was this guy to my girlfriend and why wouldn’t she tell me about him?

I asked her about it and the more I asked, the less it seemed like she wanted to talk about it. Finally, she admitted to me that she had been married before and this was her ex husband. I was shocked; she had told me she’d never been married! Obviously I wanted to know more, like what happened, why didn’t she tell me about him all that stuff. Btu the more I asked her about the marriage, the became really evasive and defensive, telling me it was a mistake and that she wanted to forget about it. After that, it was like a wall came down. No more talking about our past, no more sharing, nothing. She just really didn’t want to talk about this guy or anything else and got upset if I brought it up.

I got suspicious, I mean, wouldn’t you be? But I’m not too bad at searching and finding people and so I did some Googling around. You can imagine the sheer shock when I discovered that not only had she been married before, but they had a kid together as well!

Doc, she had been hiding this from me the entire time we had been dating. I know you say people are allowed to have their secrets but this is something I think I had a right to know! All of this made me question whether I could trust her anymore or if I even knew her at all! I confronted her about it, and she admitted to lying to me but said she was afraid of how I would react if I knew the truth.

I feel like I’ve been betrayed by someone I care about deeply. I don’t care that she was married before, but the fact that she lied about it bothers me. It bothers me a LOT. I don’t know if I can continue to be with her knowing she was willing to hide such a significant part of her life from me. What else is she lying to me about? What should I do?

Sincerely,

Betrayed

DEAR BETRAYED: Hoo boy. I REALLY hope this one isn’t real, because this, potentially is one hell of a mess, one way or another.

But let’s assume for a minute that this is legit.

This is one of those times when I am honestly conflicted, Betrayed. On the one hand, yeah, that’s a pretty big thing to lie about. And yes, actively saying she never been married and neglecting to mention that she had a child are lies. One is an active lie and the other’s a lie of omission. Those are things that can shake you to the core.

On the other hand… I don’t know if I would call this a betrayal, per se. I could see it being a betrayal if she were still married and you discovered that she was cheating on her husband with you, or if this were a case of out-and-out fraud or something. Leaving this relationship out of her list of past lovers… I don’t know if that would reach the level of betrayal, in my opinion. A shock to the system, absolutely. Something that would make you question how well you know her at all? For sure. Betrayal? I don’t know. Betrayal, to me, would be a pretty high bar to clear, especially just for leaving one relationship off the list – a significant relationship, to be sure, but still.

The reason why I’m hemming and hawwing is that, while I can understand why you’ve been rocked by this revelation, I can also see a lot of reasons why she might not want to talk about this guy.

You’re right: I’m firmly of the opinion that relationships aren’t depositions and we’re not required to share literally everything about our lives. You aren’t required to roll out everything about you right off the bat, especially if it involves aspects of you, your life or your past that aren’t going to immediately affect your relationship. Even then, everyone, even married couples, are allowed zones of autonomy and allowed to have secrets and private shames.

But that qualifier – “immediately affect your relationship” – is going to be an important one. And an ex-husband (and child) coming back into someone’s life is going to be a pretty big damn effect.

A lot is going to come down to precisely what happened with this marriage, why it ended and why she didn’t want to bring it up, or the fact that she had a child. It doesn’t sound to me like she was actively trying to deceive you, or trick you into thinking she was someone that she wasn’t. Similarly, it doesn’t sound to me like she was trying to lure you into a relationship under false pretenses by hiding something she knew would be a dealbreaker until it was too late.

If anything, this sounds more like she was trying to conceal something she was ashamed of. Or, worse, something she was afraid of.

If, for example, she left her ex because he was abusive or dangerous, I could entirely understand why she would want to keep that part of her life quarantined off from everything else, especially near the start of a relationship. That’s some pretty heavy shit to lay on somebody, and talking about it before she’s ready could dredge up trauma that she’d rather not experience again. Similarly, if she were actively fleeing this guy, cutting as many potential ties as possible would make it less likely that he could track her down and re-enter her life.

The fact that she says that being married to him was a mistake suggests to me that there’s more to the relationship and her past with him. This could be anything from youthful indiscretion to there being bigger issues in her past tied up with him… things that she would rather not dig into, either now or possibly ever.

But there’s also the child, involved here. Having a child, but either leaving them behind or losing custody can feel deeply shameful. Admitting that she abandoned a child is tantamount to admitting to be an awful person, even if there were reasons for it. The same would be true if she lost custody to her ex-husband, whether for legitimate reasons or not.

While I’m not saying this excuses not bringing them up, not wanting to parade what may have been an awful time in her life or a period when she was a horrible person would be pretty understandable. Especially when you’re still very much in the early stages of a relationship, like you two were.

Now none of this is to say that you’re wrong for feeling the way you feel. Your feelings are real and they’re valid. This has been a series of world-rocking revelations in short order, and it changes what you know about your girlfriend. You, quite reasonably, have every reason to question… if not everything, then significant amounts of what you thought you knew. But even so, it’s a question of whether this new information is an “instead of” or an “in addition to”. And the only person who can answer that question is your girlfriend.

But what do you do now? Well, if you aren’t ready to end the relationship immediately over this – which is a legitimate option – then I think you and she need to have a long and detailed discussion about this. This may be a conversation you would have had eventually, but it’s absolutely one that will need to happen now.

While I realize this may be difficult, you’re going to need to try to be as non-judgmental as possible when talking with her about this. This may well be a thorny and difficult topic. If she’s as wonderful a person as you say, then her leaving a husband and child behind, whatever the circumstances, was likely not easy.

(If it was easy, then it’s time to GTFO at speed. Leaving a marriage is one thing. Leaving a child is another.)

Condemning her, judging her or otherwise making her feel worse is only going to make her less likely to tell you her story, not more so. If you have any desire to keep this relationship going, then letting her share this will mean swallowing a lot of knee-jerk responses and letting her get the whole story out. It may well not be what you think.

But that’s a mighty big “if”, and I certainly couldn’t blame you if this was too much or the shock of it all was too big to get over.

Can you ever trust her again? Well, a lot is going to depend. Are you willing to extend that trust to her? If you aren’t, or you can’t, then you should end things now; prolonging things if you know you can’t forgive and forget is just cruel. If you are willing to trust her again, then she has to be willing to earn that trust back and demonstrate her trustworthiness by being absolutely above board on pretty much everything. That doesn’t mean she’s not allowed her privacy, but it does mean that she’s going to need to be mindful about what you do and don’t need to know.

All that being said: this is still very early in the relationship. If you’re going to have trust issues at six months… well, even if she comes clean and explains everything, I think this relationship may have problems going the distance.

My advice would be to at least hear her out and then decide how you feel. Just proceed with caution; this clearly isn’t easy for either of you.

Good luck.

Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com

DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I (F, 27) been seeing this guy (M, 26) for a few months now. He’s incredibly sweet, our chemistry is great when we’re together, except for one thing—he’s always on his phone. Whenever we’re together, he’s constantly texting or scrolling through social media. It’s becoming a real issue because, when he’s present, he’s amazing. But when he isn’t, it feels like he’s not even aware that I’m there. Either I feel like he forgets I’m there with him, or I’m made to feel like I’m somehow interrupting him from something more important.

It would be hard enough if this was about work and his job kept getting in the way of us spending time together. I wouldn’t like it, but at least I wouldn’t feel like I’m not entertaining enough for him. But it’s not. He’s replying to group chats on WhatsApp, reading his Discords or Twitter. There were even a few times when I realized he was watching TikToks instead of being with me.

At first, I didn’t want to make a big deal out of it, but as time went on, it started to bother me more and more. It’s not just an occasional issue, it’s all the time. If we sit down to dinner, his phone comes out. If we’re on the couch and not actively making out or something, the phone comes out. I’ve tried bringing it up in a gentle way, but he always seems to brush it off, saying that it’s just habit or that he’s not really paying attention to his phone

It’s starting to feel like I’m competing for his attention with his phone, and I’m losing. I really like him, but I want to be with someone who is present and engaged when we’re together. What should I do?

Digital Widow

DEAR DIGITAL WIDOW: Ooof. This letter hits a little too close to home, DW. I am emphatically someone who spends entirely too much time online and who’s more or less glued to his phone. And as someone who’s had partners who’ve gently pointed out that I seem to be unable to stop scrolling Twitter or who whips his phone out the moment he gets bored… I’m not that far off from your beau.

But the fact that I can relate to your boyfriend might be a benefit in this case, because I may be able to provide context that could help.

Much like you and your boyfriend, I’ve had partners complain that I spend a lot of time on my phone – even when watching TV or otherwise engaged with things I presumably like. What was so compelling about scrolling through social media over shows I actually enjoyed watching or spending time with people I cared about.

Well as it turns out, the answer was, in part, that I have ADHD. I didn’t get my diagnosis until 2020, when the pandemic and the lockdown disrupted the majority of my coping mechanisms, and getting that diagnosis was very much the Rosetta Stone of many of my odd personality quirks.

One of the defining traits of ADHD is that it interferes with the brain’s ability to produce, absorb and metabolize dopamine; people with ADHD are basically running on a dopamine deficiency, and as a result, we’re always trying to reach a baseline by finding other sources. This leaves us easily distracted, in part, because we’re trying to find the next “hit”, and hyperfocus happens when our brains are determined to wring every last drop of that sweet, sweet happy juice out of whatever we’re currently doing.

Because novelty is one of the easiest and most effective ways of generating dopamine, we often end up getting addicted to our smartphones. Between the ever-burning trash fire of social media, quick and easily consumed bites of content via TikTok or Instagram, never-ending streams of emails and 24 hour news and content cycles, our smartphones are functionally perpetual dopamine factories, forever supplying us with the novelty that lets our brains get the fix they need.

And to make matters worse, people with ADHD also frequently have issues with impulsivity – that is, we rarely think about potential consequences of our actions and leap before we look. So we often miss that middle step between the desire to check out whatever Elon’s done to Twitter this time and pulling out our phones to check – that middle step that says “doing this will make my girlfriend feel like she’s being ignored and maybe I should not do this.”

Before I got my diagnosis, I was very much like your boyfriend. I didn’t think I was ignoring the people around me, I didn’t think I was paying that much attention to my phone or that I was capable of multitasking and that it wasn’t taking away from my ability to be present and in the moment with people I cared about. It was only after I started getting treatment that I was able to start getting things more under control.

(Please notice very carefully that I said more under control. This is still something I have to be mindful of, because it takes very little to fall back into it. The eternal scroll of social media is decidedly something that makes the hyperfocus go BRRRRRRRRRRRRR)

So, I think it may be worth your time to ask your boyfriend if he’s ever been tested for ADHD, or if he’s under treatment. If he hasn’t, I think it would be worth his while and yours for him to talk to a doctor. If he is dealing with an undiagnosed case, like I was, then the odds are good that this is affecting him in ways beyond his being rude and inconsiderate when he’s with you. It’s almost certainly interfering in his life in other areas, often in ways that likely frustrate and mystify him the way that his behavior is currently bothering you. Getting treatment will go a long, long way to improving the overall quality of his life and his relationship with you.

However, I want to be clear: the possibility that he has ADHD explains his behavior, it doesn’t excuse it. His behavior doesn’t become acceptable just because he’s neurodivergent, and it’s no less rude just because it’s a mental health issue. He may be swimming upstream – metaphorically speaking – but his behavior is still affecting you, and he’s being inconsiderate of you and your feelings. That’s relationship poison, no matter the underlying reason. So while his getting tested and treated – assuming that he has ADHD – will help, he’s still going to have to make a point of being more engaged with you and less on his phone.

Who knows, you and he may be able to find a way to compromise, where you can have some “separate but together” time, where you’re both enjoying each other’s company by being physically present, but not necessarily doing things together. A lot of people with ADHD find this form of “parallel play” helpful, both for productivity and a general sense of companionship and connection.

That being said: I feel obligated to say that even if he does get a diagnosis, treatment may still be difficult. Right now there’s a major Adderall shortage in the US, and a lot of people are struggling to get their prescriptions filled, either regularly or at all. So there may a long period of struggle and trying to find effective coping mechanisms in the interim, especially if other medications don’t work as effectively for him.

If he doesn’t have it – or he does, but doesn’t change his behavior – well, then you and he will need to sit and have that Awkward Conversation about how he’s behaving, how it’s making you feel, and why this is a problem, even if he doesn’t think it’s that big of a deal. His opinion that it’s not that much of an issue doesn’t negate how it’s affecting you. And if he’s not willing to change his behavior in the name of, y’know, not alienating his girlfriend… well then he’ll have made his choice between you and his phone.

And it’ll be your choice as to whether you’re willing to come in second to a piece of technology.

Good luck.

Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com

DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I’ve (22m) been a reader for a couple of years and I’ve really enjoyed your work. Now I’m writing with a question of my own. I got out of my first relationship with a woman (24f) a couple of months ago. I thought things were going well, but they were very clear at first they wanted a casual relationship, and while I agreed at the time, I came to realize that I wanted something more than that and we had to break up. It was hard; while we had great immediate chemistry, we lived in different towns and so travel was always a bit of an issue. As well, there was a libido mismatch, where I had a higher libido than she did. This was made more difficult by us both living in our parents homes in our towns, and her not wanting to really hang out at our own houses. As a result, the only place we could actually have sex was my place in the town by my university, a few hours from where she lived.

This made intimacy fairly difficult, and she only came over here once out of the few months we dated. This was made even more difficult by her starting to work two jobs and take on more projects outside of that for her career a couple months after we started dating. It ended when after I brought up wanting to be more intimate, and her telling me that an arrangement where we shared our needs with each other would make the relationship too serious and not casual like she wanted, and she suspected I wanted more of a girlfriend than she was able to give due to her fun past relationship hang-ups. I realized she was right and I ended it. Throughout (although I never brought this up) I was kinda envious of the ex she mentioned she had a long term relationship with because they had that long term relationship instead of a short term one, if that makes any sense. That probably should’ve tipped me off that a casual relationship with this person wasn’t what I wanted. The whole time I was pretty anxious about losing them, which they apparently never realized, but it certainly wasn’t putting me in a healthy mental space.

It’s been two months now and I have a lot of complicated feelings about the issue. This has probably been the worst stretch of the breakup for me since the initial couple of weeks, and I’ve been having difficulty getting over it.

Theoretically, I know this relationship had to end and that I wouldn’t have been happy with a casual relationship anymore, especially the casual relationship we had. However, I still miss this person and I still really like them. As well, I was quite insecure about my virginity and being single prior to losing it in this relationship, and I’ve noticed that crop up in the wake of the breakup. I’ve felt like this would be my last ever relationship or I’d never have sex again (I know this isn’t healthy or true though). I think this cropped up in the relationship as well, where I was bothered that we weren’t as sexual as I would’ve liked. But I kinda feel a bit hopeless now. I’ve also been starting to have “what if” scenarios of if I could’ve saved the relationship.

As well, I’ve had thoughts of reaching out to her again even though I know it’s a bad idea. Part of me feels like I could handle the casual relationship just to be with her, which I know is a rationalization. There’s also, to be honest, the fact that I would be having sex in this relationship. This is a bad basis to start something up with obviously, but I still feel insecure about this.

I guess I just want advice on if there’s any way to help get over this person. I’ve had second thoughts on breaking up with this person even though I know I shouldn’t, and I was wondering if you had any tips on moving forward and coping with this, especially with how it’s started tying into my anxieties. I know this is a bit messy, but the insight is pretty valuable for me

Thanks,

Second And Third Thoughts

DEAR SECOND AND THIRD THOUGHTS: I want to preface this by saying that I’m sorry that things ended for you and your ex, and it’s understandable that you’re having some pretty complex feelings about the entire experience. And while I realize this isn’t necessarily going to help you feel better under the circumstances, SATT, but as far as first relationships go… I think this was a good experience for you.

Not, y’know, the heartache and disappointment, obviously, but what you can take from this.

It’s an unfortunate truth – and something we as a culture don’t talk about often – but our first serious relationships tend to be… well, for lack of a better term, “starter” relationships. It’s very rare that our first relationship is our last one. I can count on the fingers of one hand, with spares left over, the number of people I know who are still with their very first partner, ever.

To be sure, it’s not exactly romantic to go into a relationship with the understanding that it’s not going to last; it doesn’t feel “realistic” so much as “pessimistic”, or that you don’t have faith or trust in your partner or care for them as much as you “should”. Similarly, I’m not saying that everyone should start their first serious relationship with one foot out the door, nor fully investing in order to avoid the pain of heartbreak if and when it ends.

What I am saying is that the thing that will help most when it comes to getting over this relationship – besides the passage of time, that is – will be making a conscious shift in your perspective and how you look at this.

The primary reason why our first relationships often don’t work is that, more often than not, they’re functionally learning experiences for us. We go into our first relationships full of theories about what to expect or what we want, fantasies about how our ideal relationship will work and all sorts of expectations based around… well, very little. If you’re lucky and had parents or siblings with good and healthy relationships, you might have a more grounded baseline of expectations, but even then, we’re going in blind. You can’t know what you don’t know, after all, and so those first relationships tend to be acts of discovery.

Committing to a person for the first time, trying to balance your individual interests and desires against the needs of your partner and the needs of the relationship and trying to adjust your life so that you have space for another person are all tricky propositions for someone who’s never had to make the attempt before. It’s not surprising that those first tentative steps into this new world are often clumsy and ungainly, like a newborn deer trying to stand up and walk.

If we take a step back and do our best to look at the situation, then we can see that this wasn’t going to work out between the two of you in the long run. There were a lot of conflicting needs and incompatibilities right from the jump. She wanted something casual, without expectation of commitment or much investment and you wanted something more serious. You wanted a greater level of intimacy and physical affection than she did. To make matters more difficult, the logistics of your relationship meant that it was going to be difficult to meet those needs, even if you and your ex had similar sex drives.

But at the same time, it was very much a learning experience for you, and you came away from this knowing some important things about yourself. For example: you’ve learned that sex and a sexual connection is important to you in a relationship. I realize this seems like one of the most obvious things ever; after all, who doesn’t want sex with their partner, especially when you’re feeling strongly about losing your virginity. What you’ve learned here, though, is that this is something you should prioritize in your relationships going forward. Since sex is important to you, one of the things you will want to look for in your future relationships is someone with a roughly equal interest or desire for sex as you. A mismatch in interest or expectations would be a sign that the two of you just aren’t compatible.

Again, this seems like it would be obvious, but you’d be surprised how many people think that prioritizing a sexual connection means that you’re shallow or not as interested in your partner as a person.

However, this lesson also ties into another important consideration: there are some areas that you can’t or shouldn’t compromise on when you’re looking for a relationship.

Case in point: your ex wanted something more casual, and you agreed to it, under the (not unreasonable) assumption that you could be OK with this. I’m hoping – and you don’t say, one way or the other – that you honestly thought you were ok with it, rather than hoping that you could change her mind. I can tell you from personal experience: agreeing to one type of a relationship in hopes that you will be able to shift it to a different type is a bad idea. If you agree to a casual relationship but with the unspoken hope that you’ll be able to move it to being more committed, you’re setting yourself up for heartache. This makes it difficult to be fully engaged with your partner or to be in the moment with them. You end up feeling insecure in your connection with them because you don’t have the illusion of security that you think commitment would provide.

(I say “illusion” because there is no way to immunize your relationship against break-ups. As the man says: you can make no mistakes and still lose.)

As a result, you find yourself waiting for the Sword of Damocles to fall, where every micro expression, vocal intonation or even the amount of time it takes your partner to return a text becomes a sign that they’re about to leave you. Not because anything is actually wrong, but because you’re already anticipating the ending.

Don’t get me wrong: I’m not saying that the break up was your fault or that you did anything wrong. Much of what happened wasn’t anyone’s fault; you went into this in good faith and it simply didn’t work out. Some of it was because of circumstance, some of it was a lack of experience and some of it was because you thought one thing about yourself and discovered that it wasn’t true. That’s not an error on your part, that’s just the difference between theory and application. You had every reason to believe those things were true about yourself in part because you never had the opportunity to test it. You were making the best decisions you could with the information you had at the time. Now that you have new information, you’ll make different decisions in the future.

It’s also entirely normal that you feel conflicted about the break up. Break ups are rough, even when you know the relationship had to end. But there is another lesson to be learned here: the desire to get back together with your ex after a break up often has more to do with nostalgia and loneliness than a real desire to try again. Thankfully, you’re self-aware to recognize this. The last thing you want is to agree to something you already know doesn’t work, just to have “a relationship” or just to be with that specific person. All that would do is sign you up for the extended dance remix of your first break up, and the heartbreak after would be that much worse.

It’s also worth remembering that those feelings – like “at least I’d be having sex” – are also rationalizations. You were already dealing with logistical issues and mismatched libidos, making sex infrequent at best. Getting back together would mean that you’d still be frustrated and craving more than she could give, but now with the increased awareness that you chose this. That will only end with your feeling bad for wanting more than she could give and feeling worse for ending things over it, knowing that this was the price of entry for being with her again.

Now, I’ve written a lot about how to speed up the process of getting over somebody, but there are two things that I think will be useful to you. The first is to think seriously about what you’ve learned in your relationship with her and how you can apply those lessons to your next relationship. Part of what makes the sting of ending your first serious relationship is a feeling of helplessness, a lack of control. Those “what-if” scenarios you’re imagining are part of trying to regain a sense of agency; you’re trying to prove to yourself that there was a way you could have avoided all of this, instead of it just happening.

However, if you take those feelings and that knowledge and internalize it, you’ll be setting yourself up for success with your future relationships. You know more about what you need from the people you date, what doesn’t work for you and what to look for before you give someone your whole heart. When you and your next sweetie sit down to have the Defining The Relationship talk, you’ll know more about what you need to ask for and what that would look like for you.

The second thing to focus on is to give yourself time. You only broke up two months ago. The wounds are still fresh, and now that you’ve had a girlfriend, the lack feels that much more profound and empty. It’s hard, to be sure, but it will fade over time.

I fully realize that platitudes like “time heals all wounds” and “this too shall pass” feel unhelpful and insufficient, but there’s actual truth to them. In time – less time than you think – you’ll have more distance and perspective on things, and this will change how you look at this relationship. It’s just a matter of gritting your teeth and getting through the rough patches. But the rough patches will happen less and less, and soon enough, you’ll be surprised to realize that the hurt has faded.

For right now? Focus on taking care of yourself. Let yourself mourn the end of this relationship and practice some effective self-care. There will be love in the future. This was not the end for you. It’s not even the beginning of the end. This break up was merely the end of the beginning.

Good luck.

Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com