DEAR SOMEONE ELSE’S MOM: When I talk to my American friends, they have a hard time understanding why I put up with what they call the bullying my mother-in-law does to me. They think I should stand up to her, but in China, where I was born and lived before coming to the U.S. as a teenager, parents and parents-in-law control their children’s lives much more than American parents do.
Advertisement
My mother-in-law is first generation Chinese and although she was born here, she still expects me to submit to what she says to me and to agree with her, even if I know she is wrong.
At times it is extremely difficult to deal with her demanding nature, but in our tradition, it is how it is.
She will be coming to visit at the end of the year, and I am already feeling anxious about the visit. When I speak to my husband about how I feel, he tells me to just listen to what his mother says and then do what I would anyway, which is how he treats her and has all his life. He does not understand how stressful it all is for me.
Do I follow my husband’s advice to ignore or my American friends’ advice to argue with my mother-in-law, like they do with theirs if they are pushed to it? --- RAISED DIFFERENTLY
DEAR RAISED DIFFERENTLY: Regardless of cultural backgrounds, successfully connecting with in-laws can be tricky.
In your case, while both your husband and your American friends may mean well, doing as they suggest could ultimately add to your stress by urging you to take actions contrary to how you were raised.
Rather than a dramatic showdown I think a little diplomacy is in order. When your mother-in-law begins her pushing, it’s your turn to gently and firmly push back, letting her know that while you see her point and appreciate her concern, you’ve already put things in place that work best for you and you intend to continue doing them your way.
If that alone doesn’t work, consider enlisting your husband to do more than ignore his mother. Ask him to back you up and confirm your way is the right way for the two of you.
I’ve found sometimes it only takes a mild to moderate unexpected display of strength to get someone to back down.