DEAR HARRIETTE: My boyfriend recently proposed to me, and I said no -- not because I don’t want to marry him, but because of how he did it. He proposed at a baseball game in front of a huge crowd, and it felt completely wrong for me. I don’t even like sports, and he knows that.
Advertisement
I’ve always dreamed of a more intimate and meaningful proposal, something that reflects who we are as a couple. Instead, I felt caught off guard, uncomfortable and even a little embarrassed. I panicked and said no in the moment, but now I’m wondering if I overreacted. The thing is, this isn’t just about the proposal itself. It makes me question whether he truly understands me and what I value. If he had put thought into making it personal and special, I would’ve said yes in a heartbeat. Now I’m left feeling disappointed, and I don’t know if I should just move past it, have him try again or take this as a sign that we might not be as compatible as I thought. Am I being unreasonable for feeling this way? Should I talk to him about redoing the proposal in a way that feels right for me, or is this a red flag about our future together? -- Proposal Gone Wrong
DEAR PROPOSAL GONE WRONG: Sit down and talk to your boyfriend. Apologize for reacting so strongly and negatively to his proposal. Explain that he caught you off guard. Then tell him specifically how you felt. Remind him that you don’t like sports, so you felt like his proposal did not take you or your feelings into consideration at all. This led you to wonder if he knows what you value. Tell him that you are open to marrying him, but now you are concerned whether you two are on the same page. Ask him to share his reasons for proposing in that way. Try not to be accusatory as you talk to him, or he might clam up and stop talking.