Say you own the stock of a company whose earnings increased dramatically over the last quarter. Expecting a nice bump up in price, you see the stock price heading in the opposite direction.
Advertisement
What happened? How could good news suddenly become bad news?
This is where analysts enter the picture.
Analysts offer a glimpse into future earnings. "The stock market is forward looking. That is, stock prices are established on the expectations that prospective investors have for the future earnings power of the firm," states an article from the American Association of Individual Investors, a nonprofit organization that seeks to educate individual investors (tinyurl.com/vcjwh5z3).
The analysts' research "often involves modeling out forecasts for how a given company might perform in the future," explained Yahoo Finance's Brian Cheung (tinyurl.com/2yj6ahyu). "Using their own math, analysts will publish estimates for figures like revenue and [earnings per share]."
Those estimates are then collected and published as 'consensus' estimates by aggregators (Bloomberg, FactSet, S&P Capital IQ and Refinitiv). When a reporter talks about beating or missing expectations, that's the source of their information.
"Earnings estimates embody investors' opinions of factors such as sales growth, product demand, competitive industry environment, profit margins and cost controls," explained the AAII staff in "Earnings Estimates and Their Impact on Stock Prices". "Stock prices adjust as these expectations change or are proven wrong."
The AAII offered some main points to keep in mind when considering earnings estimates:
-- "Firms with high expected earnings growth tend to underperform the market because it is difficult to meet the market's high expectations. Companies with low earnings expectations tend to do better than expected."
-- "Realize that the stock price already reflects the general consensus about future earnings. Be aware that if a stock is highly touted, the basis for the recommendation should be an earnings forecast significantly above the prevailing opinion."
It turns out that the majority of S&P 500 companies do beat estimates. Randy Frederick, managing director of trading and derivatives at the Schwab Center for Financial Research, wrote in 2023 that about 78% of companies in the S&P 500 Index had "beaten their estimates on a quarterly basis since 2020" (tinyurl.com/32nd9vk4).
Frederick added that "Company executives -- who provide the earnings guidance that analysts use to create their estimates -- are loath to disappoint investors. Just as airlines can pad flight times to avoid being considered late, company executives can issue conservative earnings guidance so it's easier to meet or beat analysts' expectations."
How else can analysts affect prices? Take this Wall Street Journal story from May 8, 2024, titled "Heard on the Street: Why Lyft's Stock is Pulling Ahead of Uber's" (tinyurl.com/45amkynh).
Reporter Dan Gallagher pointed out that "Lyft has buy ratings from only 21% of the analysts covering the shares ... a sharp contrast to the 90% of analysts who rate arch-rival Uber as a buy, according to FactSet data."
However, Gallagher wrote, "low expectations can also be a blessing. Lyft's stock jumped 7% Wednesday following its results, which showed gross bookings for the first quarter of about $3.7 billion, 3% ahead of analysts' estimates." As for Uber, the first-quarter results "showed gross bookings of $37.65 billion, which was about 1% below Wall Street's target." Gallagher went on to note that "Uber's stock slipped nearly 6% on Wednesday."
As you might expect, consensus estimates are not an exact science. Plus, consensus "may not capture what the best analysts think about a company's prospects. A few analysts tend to make remarkably accurate earnings forecasts, while others can miss them by a mile," quoting Ben McClure of Investopedia.
McClure goes a step further by telling investors to search for analysts with the best track records for accurate forecasts (tinyurl.com/48j93umj).
Expectations do play a role in stock prices when earnings are released. But, in the end, it's buyers and sellers that actually set prices through millions of buy and sell orders.
DISTRIBUTED BY ANDREWS MCMEEL SYNDICATION